In the lawsuit, the plaintiffs seek relief before the April 30 effective date and guidance on applying a new lower interest rate on money judgments retroactively.
04/07/2022 10:00 A.M.
4 minute read
New York’s Fair Consumer Judgment Interest Act (FCJIA), which will lower the interest rate on money judgments in actions involving consumer debt by nearly 80%, is the subject of several credit unions’ filing for a class-action lawsuit and injunctive relief before the law takes effect on April 30.
The FCJIA amends Section 5004 of the civil practice law and rules to lower the statutory rate of interest accrued by judgments arising from consumer debt from 9% to 2% per annum.
In the complaint filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, plaintiffs Greater Chautauqua Federal Credit Union, Boulevard Federal Credit Union, and the Greater Niagara Federal Credit Union, challenge defendants that would enforce the new law and judgment rates, including New York Chief Administrative Judge Lawrence K. Marks, the Chautauqua County Sheriff’s Office, Erie County Sheriff’s Office, and Niagara County Sheriff’s Office, and seek a class-action case on behalf of judgment creditors and a jury trial.
In addition to recalculating the statutory interest that has accrued on judgments arising from “consumer debts,” the complaint alleges that judgment creditors with pending post-judgment executions in place must, at their own expense and within 60 days of April 30, file amended executions with the sheriff or other enforcement officer so that the execution reflects the recalculated interest and total judgment debt.
“Despite the [a]mendment’s mandate for swift action by judgment creditors, implementing sheriffs, and court officials, the [a]mendment provides virtually no guidance on how to apply a retroactive recalculation or on the consequences of a failure to issue an amended execution,” the plaintiffs argue.
The goal of the FCJIA, according to its authors, is to “remedy the hardship placed on a significant number of New Yorkers by a statutory judgment interest rate that has long been incommensurate with market interest rates, and which has been intensified by the COVID-10 pandemic,” as ACA International previously reported
The law defines consumer debt as “any obligation or alleged obligation of any natural person to pay money arising out of a transaction in which the money, property, insurance or services which are the subject of the transaction are primarily for personal, family or household purposes, whether or not such obligation has been reduced to judgment, including, but not limited to, a consumer credit transaction, as defined in [CPLR Sec. 105].”
As signed by New York Gov. Kathy Hochul, the law will apply the 2% rate of interest to unpaid consumer-debt judgments beginning on April 30, and will apply that rate retroactively to any consumer-debt judgments entered prior to the effective date for judgments that have not yet been fully paid as of the effective date.
Judgment Rates Impact Revenue, Loans
The plaintiffs state in their complaint the requirements for applying the retroactive recalculation and lack of guidance on how to comply caused “widespread confusion” among judgment creditors and supporters of the amendment alike, including during the legislative process to pass the amendment last year.
Invoking the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment and the Due Process Clause of the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, the plaintiffs argue that the defendants’ acts to implement the new law will deprive the plaintiffs of their property without just compensation or due process.
The plaintiffs seek to represent a class of New York judgment holders of unsatisfied consumer-debt judgments entered in New York state courts before the law’s April 30 effective date.
According to the complaint, creditors like the plaintiffs “rely on interest that accrues on judgments to offset the costs of recovering the debts and the cost of inflation when the judgment debts are not paid immediately. If creditors are unable to rely on sufficient interest to offset the cost of recovering judgment debts, the lending industry will be forced to raise interest rates on loans and reduce the number of loans offered to higher-risk borrowers. The result will be that credit will become less available to borrowers.”
Additionally, the plaintiffs argue that some businesses may purchase loans, accounts and judgments relying on the 9% per annum rate. The price of these purchases and interest will continue to accrue, and if that rate is lowered on a retroactive basis, these purchasers unfairly lose a significant portion of their investment.
The plaintiffs seek a preliminary injunction to enjoin the effective date of the amendment in the FCJIA and ultimately a jury trial.
Read the complaint here.
If you have executive leadership updates or other member news to share with ACA, contact our communications department at comm@acainternational.org. View our publications page for more information and our news submission guidelines here.
In the lawsuit, the plaintiffs seek relief before the April 30 effective date and guidance on applying a new lower interest rate on money judgments retroactively.








