ACA outlines concerns with the final rule from stakeholders and members of Congress.
01/08/2025 12:30 P.M.
3.5 minute read
A day after the CFPB put out an enforcement action penalizing a mortgage lender for failing to consider medical debt, the bureau twisted itself in circles by releasing a final rule arguing that medical debt should not be considered on credit reports. U.S. health care providers and small businesses pay the price for the CFPB’s contradictory actions with unclear rules and a more limited ability to provide credit and health care services. All Americans pay the price with increased costs and less available credit.
Medical debt is a serious challenge for many Americans and this CFPB rule does nothing to fix the underlying problems. It does not address the complex web of health insurance. It simply shifts the burden of payment onto doctors, nurses and all other patients, for those who have not paid.
The same issue has occurred in the debate over student loan forgiveness. The problem of expensive education is not solved by shifting the payment burden onto current or former students.
During the CFPB’s public comment period, a significant number of commenters warned of the rule’s potential long-term negative consequences. They argued that health care providers unable to rely on payment plans to satisfy the co-pay and/or deductible would require full payment in advance before providing services. Commenters also predicted higher costs and insurance premiums, noting that the rule would not eliminate medical debt, but instead redistribute the cost across other portions of the population.
The rule includes an unusual exception: if consumers self-report medical debt, creditors must then follow another complex regulation about ability-to-repay requirements
According to its own estimates in the rule finalized this week, the CFPB’s actions will create a market shift of billions of dollars. This is a serious matter. It means doctors and hospitals across America will feel the impact and could even be forced to close practices in rural and underserved areas of the country.
The CFPB won’t acknowledge this serious issue because it does not fit into its post-election political narrative; however, the country has already spoken about concerns when overreaching government regulators do not consider real-world implications of their actions.
This final rule will harm medical providers, patients, consumers, and creditors, not to mention the larger economy. This is why major policy changes should come from Congress, not from regulators seeking politically appealing soundbites that don’t fully consider the actual impact on everyday Americans.
In August 2024 members of Congress wrote to CFPB Director Rohit Chopra to express their “serious concerns” about the rule. They warned the proposed rule presented “significant negative effects on access and affordability of credit for all consumers, and particularly for low-income borrowers.” They focused their comment on the calculated approach on medical debt credit reporting in the FCRA and Regulation V.
As House Financial Services Chairman French Hill outlined in a Jan. 8 statement, this “will drive up costs to any American seeking medical care and have a devastating impact on consumers’ access to healthcare in rural areas.”
The text of FCRA is clear— contrary to contentions that reporting medical debt is a loophole, Congress intended for the federal banking agencies and the National Credit Union Association to determine the “necessary and appropriate [use of medical information] to protect legitimate operational, transactional, risk, consumer, and other needs … in connect with any determination of the consumer’s eligibility or continued eligibility for credit.”
Congress had a front seat to the 2007 financial crisis and understands that making lending decisions without sufficient information harms consumers and makes it more difficult to lend.
Perhaps the most troubling aspect of this rule is the irony. The Dodd Frank Act created the CFPB, in part, to reduce the likelihood of consumers receiving loans they can’t afford to repay.
ACA is evaluating all options to stop the CFPB’s medical debt credit reporting rule, which conflicts with Congress’s clear direction on medical debt credit reporting, and to support an efficient and effective credit granting process, and this rule fails to provide data-driven support for its actions.
###
ACA International (ACA), the association of credit and collection professionals, is the largest membership organization in the accounts receivable management industry. Founded in 1939, ACA brings together third-party collection agencies, law firms, asset buying companies, creditors and vendor affiliates representing industry professionals. ACA produces a wide variety of products, services and publications, including educational and compliance-related information; and articulates the value of the accounts receivable management industry to businesses, policymakers and consumers. www.acainternational.org.
ACA outlines concerns with the final rule from stakeholders and members of Congress.

