The hearing reviewed the law, which created the CFPB, and its unintended outcomes for regulated businesses.
07/17/2025 2:00 P.M.
4 minute read
Policies from the Dodd-Frank Act have “burdened U.S. public companies,” said U.S. Rep. French Hill, R-Ark., in opening remarks at a House Financial Services Committee hearing July 15: “Dodd-Frank Turns 15: Lessons Learned and the Road Ahead.”
Hill, who chairs the committee, called the hearing to review the real-world impact of Dodd-Frank and its unintended consequences for businesses.
“Dodd-Frank was sold to the American people as a sweeping fix to prevent another crisis, yet over time it has become clear that this approach has not delivered as promised for Main Street,” Hill said. “Instead, history shows that it punished community financial institutions through its one-size-fits-all mandates, shifted activity outside the banking system, created new and unaccountable agencies like the [Consumer Financial Protection Bureau], and prioritized duplicative compliance and regulation by enforcement over actual consumer protection.”
Testifying before the committee were Ken Bentsen, president and CEO, Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association; Lindsey Johnson, president and CEO, Consumer Bankers Association; Tom Quaadman, chief of government affairs and public policy, Investment Company Institute; Paul Kupiec, senior fellow, American Enterprise Institute, co-founder, president, and CEO Better Markets; and Dennis Kelleher, co-founder, president, and CEO Better Markets.
In addition to general Dodd-Frank reform, the discussion focused on the state of the CFPB.
“The law created new agencies, like the CFPB, which has operated with unprecedented autonomy and minimal accountability to Congress or the American people,” Hill said. “For 15 years, we’ve lived under the shadow of Dodd-Frank.”
Hill also stressed that regulations under the Dodd-Frank Act are “overbearing” for financial institutions and that they stifle their contribution to economic growth and innovation.
He asked the witness panel about the impact of the law’s regulatory framework on market conditions, or if it only increased confusion and difficulty for businesses to navigate its requirements.
Kupiec responded that the regulations are “overly complex” yet do not address essential areas such as interest rate risk that banks, for example, need to know about.
Members of the committee, including U.S. Reps. Ann Wagner, R-Mo., and John Rose, R-Tenn., discussed how Congress can clarify policies from the Dodd-Frank Act, perhaps through additional legislation.
Regarding the CFPB, Committer Ranking Member Maxine Waters, D-Calif., focused on the impact of efforts to slow it down while others addressed if changes at the bureau are politically motivated.
U.S. Rep. Gregory Meeks, D-N.Y., said he would support changing the leadership structure of the bureau to a bipartisan commission.
U.S. Rep. William Timmons, R-S.C., asked the witness panel how the CFPB could adopt a more focused approach to regulations, which Johnson suggested would require more defined authority measures and a cost-benefit analysis.
Following the hearing, the committee may conduct a markup of CFPB reform legislation and other changes to Dodd-Frank.
For example, the Consumer Financial Protection Commission Act (PDF) would establish the CFPB as an independent agency led by a bipartisan commission.
Additional legislation would clarify the bureau’s standards for Unfair, Deceptive Abusive Acts or Practices enforcement actions (PDF) and its practices for issuing civil investigative demands (PDF).
“As we examine the last 15 years, I hope we can do so with clear eyes,” Hill said. “It’s also time to take a hard look at the rules that never made sense in the first place, rules that sit on the shelf and create needless uncertainty for market participants, just waiting for an unelected bureaucrat to dust them off and use them. That’s not how our system should work. We must work together to craft thoughtful, bipartisan reforms that restore balance, foster growth, and protect consumers.”
Meanwhile, the CFPB will see funding changes as a result of the sweeping federal tax and spending legislation passed earlier this month.
The One Big Beautiful Bill Act reduces the CFPB funding to 6.5%, instead of 12%, from the Federal Reserve, ACA International previously reported.
The House Financial Services Committee proposed a cap of 5%, while the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs revised its proposal from 0% in funding to 6.5% which ultimately passed in the bill.
The spending cap will likely result in a reduction in staff and/or cuts to other spending, according to a Congressional Research Service (CRS) summary of the bill.
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.





