A summary of recent top FCRA, TCPA and FDCPA cases from ACA. Editor’s note: This article is available for members only.
03/18/2022 10:45 A.M.
4.5 minute read
Each week, ACA International’s compliance team covers relevant case summaries for ACA members. Members may also submit cases for consideration to our compliance team at dailydecision@acainternational.org.
Here are the cases covered March 15 – 18:
March 15
Jackson v. Klein: Credit Reporting Error Amounted to a Mistake of Law
An Illinois district court held that the defendant’s reliance on the Consumer Data Industry Association’s credit reporting guidelines when it interpreted its obligations under the FDCPA reflected an error of law that was ineligible for the bona fide error defense.
Continue reading the summary here.
Miller v. I.C. System: Collector Wins Some FDCPA Claims on Summary Judgment
If a contract resulting in a debt requires the consumer to pay the “costs incurred” in debt collection efforts, such costs must have actually been incurred as of the date the consumer received their collection letters. When parties do not present sufficient evidence of what costs were incurred by the creditor or when, the court must deny summary judgment on this issue.
Continue reading the summary here.
Adler v. Penn Credit: Court Finds Consumer Failed to Prove an Injury-In-Fact
A consumer sued a debt collector over confusion caused by a collection letter he received that had two different addresses for the debt collector. The court found that the consumer had not stated an injury-in-fact and granted summary judgment to the debt collector.
Continue reading the summary here.
March 16
Faherty v. D&A Services: Validation Notice Was Not Misleading
A Connecticut district court found that, when read as a whole, the validation language in a collection notice was not false or misleading.
Continue reading the summary here.
Napoleon v. Shows, Cali & Walsh: Court Denies Both Parties’ Motion for Summary Judgment
The consumer received a grant to fix the damage to his home caused by hurricanes Katrina and Rita. The state sued the consumer through its attorneys claiming the consumer did not execute the terms of the grant. The consumer filed a lawsuit claiming the attorneys violated the FDCPA by attempting to collect a debt that was not owed by the consumer. Both parties moved for summary judgment.
Continue reading the summary here.
Tescher v. Experian Info. Sols: Court Denies Credit Furnisher’s Motion to Dismiss FCRA Claims that Alleged Its Investigation Was Insufficient
Certain issues, such as the reasonableness of a furnisher’s investigation into a consumer’s dispute, are fact-intensive. Information about the precise nature of the furnisher’s investigation is uniquely in the hands of the furnisher and so a consumer cannot be expected to have much more information about the reasonableness of the investigation at the early stages of the litigation than the consumer has stated in his complaint, and courts may permit such claims to proceed.
Continue reading the summary here.
March 17
Jovanovic v. SRP: Defendant Did Not Use ATDS
The plaintiff’s allegations that the defendant used a long code number to send a personalized message weighed against the conclusion that the text was sent using an ATDS.
Continue reading the summary here.
Otto v. TransUnion: Court Grants Partial Dismissal of FCRA Claims
A court sided with the majority view that a furnisher who repeatedly reports a delinquent account as charged-off is not inaccurate and has not violated the FCRA.
Continue reading the summary here.
Paxton v. LVNV: Magistrate Judge Dismisses Claim Based on Rooker-Feldman Doctrine
The consumer claims she was served at an address where she never resided and in a state she no longer lived. This resulted in a default judgment the consumer only found out about when her employer emailed her a notice of garnishment. The consumer sued, claiming FDCPA violations. The debt collector contended her suit must fail because it was precluded by the Rooker-Feldman doctrine.
Continue reading the summary here.
March 18
Flores v. Debski & Assocs: Conclusory Allegations Were Insufficient to Establish FDCPA Claims
A consumer failed to establish all of the elements of an FDCPA claim because he did not identify in his compliant essential information about the alleged debt, including the form of the debt, or when the debt was incurred.
Continue reading the summary here.
McGee v. State Collection Serv.: Mere Confusion Is Not an Injury-in-Fact
The consumer claimed that the debt collector sent him a confusing letter. The debt collector moved to dismiss for lack of Article III standing.
Continue reading the summary here.
Sinegal v. Big Horn Auto Sales: Court Allows FDCPA Claims Involving Repo Agent to Proceed
Where a consumer’s claim under the FDCPA Section 1692f(6) was against a repossession agency, not an auto dealer, and the agency did not move to dismiss the claim, the court found that under the governing state law on the issue of whether a secured party had a ‘present right’ to possession of collateral, the dealer failed to show that the agency had a right to repossess the vehicle. For this reason, the court denied the dealer’s motion to dismiss.
Continue reading the summary here.
Visit the Industry Advancement Fund webpage for more Daily Decision recaps and compliance resources.
If you’ve recently obtained a judicial opinion that might benefit other ACA members, email it to us: dailydecision@acainternational.org.
- Join the discussion on legal and compliance topics with your fellow members on the Members Attorney Program community on The Hub. Simply log on to The Hub and select Members Attorney Program under the Communities menu.
- ACA’s Daily Decision is powered by ACA’s Litigation Advocacy and Compliance Teams.
To receive notifications about ACA content—including member alerts, upcoming events and new products—text ALERTS to 96997. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency will vary. To opt-out at any time, reply STOP to any message we send.
A summary of recent top FCRA, TCPA and FDCPA cases from ACA. Editor’s note: This article is available for members only.








