A summary of recent top FCRA, TCPA and FDCPA cases from ACA. Editor’s note: This article is available for members only.
04/29/2022 2:00 P.M.
5 minute read
Each week, ACA International’s compliance team covers relevant case summaries for ACA members. Members may also submit cases for consideration to our compliance team at dailydecision@acainternational.org.
Here are the cases covered April 26 – April 29:
April 26:
Morton v. O’Brien: Court Denies Defendant’s Post-Trial on Standing
An Ohio district court denied the defendant’s post-trial motion that the plaintiff lacked standing, finding instead that the plaintiff’s allegations that her emotional state ‘manifested’ into physical ailments were sufficient to meet the standing requirements of Article III.
Continue reading the summary here.
Sherman v. Portfolio Recovery Assocs.: Court Finds Debt Collector Adequately Verified Consumer’s Debt
A consumer disputed a debt that appeared on her credit report. The debt collector provided her with verification of the debt. The consumer claimed the verification provided was not enough and requested further documentation. After sending the initial verification, the debt collector sued the consumer in state court. The suit was dismissed and the consumer sued the debt collector for violating the FDCPA and FCRA.
Continue reading the summary here.
Badwan v. Wells Fargo: FCRA Claims Against Furnisher Dismissed
The court found a furnisher is not responsible for determining who is “at fault” for a consumer’s missed payments because such a finding would involve the sort of judgment that the FCRA neither expects nor requires furnishers of information to make.
Continue reading the summary here.
April 27
Shadrin v. Student Loan Solutions: Court Finds Plaintiff Sufficiently Alleged Debts Were Time-Barred
A Maryland district court found the plaintiffs in this case sufficiently alleged that letters sent by a previous debt collector accelerated their debts, thereby bringing the debts outside of the statute of limitations.
Continue reading the summary here.
Rembert v. American Coradius International: Court Remands Hunstein Copycat Case to State Court
A consumer alleged a debt collector violated the FDCPA by sending her a dunning letter that was prepared by a “letter vendor” that had a barcode visible on the envelope. The case was removed to federal court. The consumer now moves to have the case remanded to state court because she did not state an injury-in-fact.
Continue reading the summary here.
Basham v. Midland Funding: Court Grants Summary Judgment for Defendants on All Claims Under FDCPA, TCPA, and FCRA
A law firm was entitled to judgment as a matter of law on a consumer’s FCRA Section 1681s-2(b) claims because it was undisputed that the law firm never credit reported any of the consumer’s accounts. As such, it could not be considered a “furnisher of information” subject to the provisions of the statute as a matter of law. The court granted the defendants’ motion for summary judgment on the FDCPA claims because the only evidence in the record demonstrated the debts were likely related to the consumer’s business and did not involve consumer debts.
Continue reading the summary here.
April 28
Johnson v. Waypoint: Court Finds Collector Could Collect Expired Debt But Couldn’t Use Bona Fide Error Defense
The FDCPA asks whether a collector had or should have had actual knowledge of a dispute, not whether the consumer could have done more to make her dispute known. The bona fide error defense requires that the procedures at issue be aimed at the specific error that occurred, not at the type of violation generally. A consumer who lacks any actual damages under the FDCPA might still be able to prove at trial they would be entitled to statutory damages.
Continue reading the summary here.
Ross v. O’Hara: Emotional Harms in FDCPA Case Did Not Satisfy Article III
An Indiana district court dismissed a consumer’s FDCPA claims because her alleged harms consisted of mostly emotional injuries described in largely abstract terms, and with no comparable evidence to show a concrete injury.
Continue reading the summary here.
Smith v. American-Amicable Life Ins.: Court Finds Consumer’s Prerecorded Message Allegations ‘Very Thin,’ Dismisses Class Action Lawsuit
A consumer claimed that a life insurance company called him twice using a prerecorded message, despite the fact that his number was registered on the National Do Not Call Registry. The consumer filed a class-action lawsuit against the insurance company, and the insurance company moved to dismiss.
Continue reading the summary here.
April 29
Samano v. LVNV Funding: Consumer Has Standing to Pursue FDCPA Claims About Disputed Accounts
A consumer alleged that a collector falsely represented his no-longer-disputed accounts to the CRAs, which constituted a material misrepresentation. The court denied the collector’s motion and reasoned that because a consumer’s dispute of a debt is always material, the fact that an account is no longer disputed would also be material.
Continue reading the summary here.
Anglin v. Merchants Credit Corp.: 9th Circuit Holds State Law Violation Not a Violation of the FDCPA
The consumers owed a medical debt, which was reduced to a judgment. However, the consumers filed a countersuit that was not resolved at the time the judgment was entered. The debt collector attempted to garnish the consumer before the countersuit was resolved and filed another lawsuit claiming a violation of the FDCPA. The district court dismissed the consumers’ case and they appealed.
Continue reading the summary here.
Weisz v. Sarma Collections: No Standing for Hunstein Copycat Claims
In another letter vendor case reminiscent of the claims in Hunstein, a New York district court granted a defendant’s motion to dismiss on the basis that the plaintiff lacked standing to pursue his FDCPA claims.
Continue reading the summary here.
Visit the Industry Advancement Fund webpage for more Daily Decision recaps and compliance resources.
If you’ve recently obtained a judicial opinion that might benefit other ACA members, email it to us: dailydecision@acainternational.org.
- Join the discussion on legal and compliance topics with your fellow members on the Members Attorney Program community on The Hub. Simply log on to The Hub and select Members Attorney Program under the Communities menu.
- ACA’s Daily Decision is powered by ACA’s Litigation Advocacy and Compliance Teams.
To receive notifications about ACA content—including member alerts, upcoming events and new products—text ALERTS to 96997. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency will vary. To opt-out at any time, reply STOP to any message we send.
A summary of recent top FCRA, TCPA and FDCPA cases from ACA. Editor’s note: This article is available for members only.








