0
Skip to content

Daily Decision Recap: Bright-Line Rules, Procedural Violations, and More

A summary of recent top FCRA, TCPA and FDCPA cases from ACA. Editor’s note: This article is available for members only.

06/10/2022 3:30 P.M.

4.5 minute read

Each week, ACA International’s compliance team covers relevant case summaries for ACA members. Members may also submit cases for consideration to our compliance team at dailydecision@acainternational.org.

Here are the cases covered June 7 – June 10:

June 7:

Snider v. PRS: Court Grants Default Judgment on Collection Text Message

A consumer received a text message from a debt collector attempting to collect a debt. The text message did not provide the disclosures required by the FDCPA. The consumer sued the debt collector, but the debt collector did not respond to the consumer’s complaint. The court granted the consumer’s default judgment against the collector.

Continue reading the summary here.

Colon v. Bayview Loan Servicing: Bankruptcy Court Grants Summary Judgment for Loan Servicer on FDCPA Claims

A bankruptcy court found it lacked subject matter jurisdiction over a consumer’s claims under the FDCPA because the claims did not relate in any way to the consumer’s 2004 bankruptcy case or the bankruptcy estate.

Continue reading the summary here.

DeMesa v. Treasure Island: TCPA Plaintiff Could Not Prove Hotel Reservation Service Used an ATDS

A Nevada district court found that because the plaintiff provided her phone number to the defendant, she could not prove that the defendant “produce[d]” her number “using a random or sequential number generator,” as required for ATDS liability under the TCPA.

Continue reading the summary here.

June 8

Cit Bank v. Neris: Federal Court Rejects New York Bright-Line Separate Envelope Rule

When faced with an apparent conflict between the requirements of the New York state mortgage foreclosure law and the FDCPA, the federal court declined to follow decisions by the state’s intermediary court.Instead, it found that the state’s highest court would conclude a bank met the requirements of state law when it included disclosures required by the FDCPA in a notice mandated by state law.

Continue reading the summary here.

Lezark v. I.C. System: Court Denies Consumer’s Motion to Reconsider His Complaint

A consumer sued a debt collector claiming the letter he received led him to believe that the debt collector would sue him when it did not intend to. The court dismissed the consumer’s case. However, the consumer countered with  a motion to reconsider his complaint.

Continue reading the summary here.

Madej v. JPMorgan Chase: TCPA Claims Fail Because Plaintiff Provided His Number to the Defendant

An Ohio district court held that “when consent to be called is given regarding an account upon which a debt is owed, the calling party is permitted to use autodialing technology and/or prerecorded messages for calls placed to both land lines and wireless numbers.”

Continue reading the summary here.

June 9

Nojovits v. Ceteris Portfolio Services: Court Dismisses Case Due to Lack of Standing

A consumer claimed she was harmed by a collection letter. The court issued an order to show cause that she suffered an injury-in-fact. The consumer did so, but the court did not find it compelling and dismissed the case.

Continue reading the summary here.

Louis v. Bluegreen Vacations: A Bare Procedural Violation Divorced from Harm Is Insufficient for Standing

In a case involving claims under the Military Lending Act, a Florida district court found the consumers’ conclusory statements that a statutory violation of the MLA caused an injury was not enough to establish Article III standing.

Continue reading the summary here.

Williamson v. Irving K Motor Co: Court Holds It Has Jurisdiction Over TCPA Claims

The court sided with the majority view and rejected the Creasy rationale, holding that the 2015 amendment to the TCPA could be severed from the robocall restriction. Because the remainder of the law was capable of functioning independently, it thus provided a basis for the consumer’s TCPA claims.

Continue reading the summary here.

June 10

Pierre v. Midland Credit Mgmt. Inc.: Dissenting Panel Objects to FDCPA Ruling by 7th Circuit

The 7th Circuit left its ruling intact, reversing a jury verdict that awarded  $350,000 in damages to a consumer and class in an FDCPA action. The appellate court refused to rehear its decision, which found the consumer lacked standing to bring her claims alleging emotional distress.

Continue reading the summary here.

Ngambo v. Bank of America: No Private Right of Action Without First Notifying CRA

A New York district court found a consumer’s FCRA claims failed because he did not assert that he notified a CRA of an alleged inaccurate debt or report by a furnisher, which would have triggered the furnisher’s duty to investigate.

Continue reading the summary here.

Meza v. Dynamic Recovery Solutions: Case Dismissed for Consumer’s Failure to Respond

A consumer sued a data furnisher in small claims court. The data furnisher had the case removed to federal court and moved to dismiss the case with prejudice. The consumer did not respond to the data furnisher’s motion. The court granted the data furnisher’s motion in part.

Continue reading the summary here.

Visit the Industry Advancement Fund webpage for more Daily Decision recaps and compliance resources.

If you’ve recently obtained a judicial opinion that might benefit other ACA members, email it to us: dailydecision@acainternational.org.

  • Join the discussion on legal and compliance topics with your fellow members on the Members Attorney Program community on The Hub. Simply log on to The Hub and select Members Attorney Program under the Communities menu.
  • ACA’s Daily Decision is powered by ACA’s Litigation Advocacy and Compliance Teams.

To receive notifications about ACA content—including member alerts, upcoming events and new products—text ALERTS to 96997. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency will vary. To opt-out at any time, reply STOP to any message we send.

If you have executive leadership updates or other member news to share with ACA, contact our communications department at comm@acainternational.org. View our publications page for more information and our news submission guidelines here.

One moment please...

Share Profile

This site utilizes cookies as included in our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.