0
Skip to content

Daily Decision Recap: ATDS Claims, “Necessaries,” and More

A summary of recent top FCRA, TCPA and FDCPA cases from ACA. Editor’s note: This article is available for members only.

06/17/2022 8:30 A.M.

4.5 minute read

Each week, ACA International’s compliance team covers relevant case summaries for ACA members. Members may also submit cases for consideration to our compliance team at dailydecision@acainternational.org.

Here are the cases covered June 14 – June 17:

June 14:

Mina v. Red Robin Int’l: Court Rejects Consumer’s Technical Description of an ATDS

The court rejected a consumer’s assertion that the TCPA’s definition of an ATDS includes a device or program that merely randomly or sequentially selects which number to dial, even if such a selection is made from a predetermined list of telephone numbers.

Continue reading the summary here.

Spino v. Rushmore Loan Management Services: Sending a Notice of Sale is Not “Collection Activity” Under the FDCPA

A Rhode Island district court held that sending a notice of a non-judicial foreclosure sale is not “collection activity” for purposes of the FDCPA.

Continue reading the summary here.

Lezark v. I.C. System Inc.: Court Dismisses Collection Letter Lawsuit 

A court found a collection letter did not violate the FDCPA because it was clear that the letter (1) was sent by a debt collector and not by a law firm; (2) created no false sense of urgency; (3) did not threaten litigation; and (4) did not suggest or imply that a lawyer had meaningfully reviewed the debtor’s account.

Continue reading the summary here.

June 15

Jackin v. Enhanced Recovery: Court Holds Consumer Can Pursue Hunstein Type Claim

A court found a consumer plausibly alleged a violation of the FDCPA when it objected to a collection agency’s use of a third-party letter vendor. The court stated it had to assume Congress meant what it said and must enforce statutes that way.

Continue reading the summary here.

Barnett v. First National Bank of Omaha: A Bank’s Dialing System Was Not an ATDS Under the TCPA

A Kentucky district court denied a plaintiff’s motion to reconsider the court’s previous ruling that the defendant’s calls were not made using an ATDS as defined under the TCPA.

Continue reading the summary here.

Meza v. Dynamic Recovery Solutions: Case Dismissed for Consumer’s Failure to Respond

A consumer sued a data furnisher in small claims court. The data furnisher had the case removed to federal court and moved to dismiss the case with prejudice. The consumer did not respond to the data furnisher’s motion. The court granted the data furnisher’s motion in part.

Continue reading the summary here.

June 16

Beal v. Outfield Brew House: 8th Circuit Finds Texting System Was Not An ATDS

The 8th Circuit Court of Appeals held that the “Txt Live” system used by two establishments to send text messages to former and potential customers was not an ATDS under the TCPA.

Continue reading the summary here.

Makhnevich v. Bougopoulos: Court Grants Summary Judgment for Collection Law Firm on All FDCPA Claims

The court rejected a consumer’s claim that a law firm engaged in “sewer service.” The consumer failed to produce admissible evidence that specifically rebutted the statements in the process server’s sworn affidavit creating a presumption that service has been effectuated in the manner described in the affidavit of service filed by the law firm.

Continue reading the summary here.

Miles v. Medicredit: Motion for Partial Judgment on the Pleadings Denied, Court Grants Request for Discovery

A consumer alleged a debt collector used an autodialer to contact him without his prior express consent. The debt collector moved for partial judgment on the pleadings in the wake of Facebook v. Duguid. The court denied the motion.

Continue reading the summary here.

June 17

Snyder v. Finley & Co: 6th Circuit Finds Lawsuit Against Spouse for “Necessaries” Violated the FDCPA

The 6th Circuit Court of Appeals found that a lawsuit filed against a consumer’s spouse for “necessaries” violated the FDCPA because the state’s law on the issue of spousal obligations requires a plaintiff first seek satisfaction of the claim from the consumer before pursing the consumer’s spouse.

Continue reading the summary here.

Gross v. TransUnion: Consumer Claims Lack of Article III Standing, Court Agrees

A consumer sued a CRA in state court for reporting false information and not correcting the credit report after he notified the CRA of the alleged error. The CRA had the case removed to federal court. The consumer moved to have the case remanded to state court for lack of Article III standing.

Continue reading the summary here.

Panzarella v. Navient: 3rd Circuit Affirms Summary Judgment for Loan Servicer on Alternative Grounds

Although the district court erred in holding that a loan servicer’s dialing system was not an ATDS because it erroneously viewed the phone server’s capacities as distinct from the other components of the overall system, the servicer was still entitled to summary judgment because there was no evidence they called the consumers’ cellphones using an ATDS without their consent.

Continue reading the summary here.

Visit the Industry Advancement Fund webpage for more Daily Decision recaps and compliance resources.

If you’ve recently obtained a judicial opinion that might benefit other ACA members, email it to us: dailydecision@acainternational.org.

  • Join the discussion on legal and compliance topics with your fellow members on the Members Attorney Program community on The Hub. Simply log on to The Hub and select Members Attorney Program under the Communities menu.
  • ACA’s Daily Decision is powered by ACA’s Litigation Advocacy and Compliance Teams.

To receive notifications about ACA content—including member alerts, upcoming events and new products—text ALERTS to 96997. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency will vary. To opt-out at any time, reply STOP to any message we send.

ACA International members are welcome to submit news items for possible publication to comm@acainternational.org.

   

If you have executive leadership updates or other member news to share with ACA, contact our communications department at comm@acainternational.org. View our publications page for more information and our news submission guidelines here.

One moment please...

Share Profile

This site utilizes cookies as included in our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.