Criminals are gaming credit reports to secure car loans they never intend to repay — and the problem has spiked 228%, TransUnion reports.
10/31/2025 11:10 A.M.
3 minute read
Auto finance fraud looks different than fraud in other lending products, and that difference is costing lenders billions annually. New research from TransUnion reveals that while auto fraud occurs less frequently than credit card or personal loan fraud, each incident hits significantly harder, with substantially higher charge-off amounts that can devastate portfolio performance.
TransUnion analyzed nearly 4.9 million loan originations across auto, card, and unsecured personal loans between March and September 2023, tracking performance through September 2025.
Among other findings, it reported that the charge-off percentage from fraud was higher among traditionally lower risk credit score tiers.
The Unique Nature of Auto Fraud
“It’s a delicate balance: tighten controls too much and you lose good customers; ease up and fraudsters slip through,” TransUnion noted in the study.
That tension is particularly acute for indirect auto lending, where dealers facilitate loans with select lenders, creating limited visibility into applicants and dealer practices.
The research identified several characteristics that distinguish auto fraud. Criminals enter the car-buying journey at multiple points, employing different tactics depending on their goals. Some engage early in the process using carefully built synthetic identities. Others strike opportunistically, exploiting weaknesses in dealer-lender workflows.
The study measured performance using two key metrics: accounts 60+ days past due within six months and charge-offs within 12 months. While auto fraud showed similar or lower incidence rates compared to cards and personal loans, the dollar impact per fraud case was dramatically higher — a reflection of the substantial loan amounts involved in vehicle financing.
Credit Washing on the Rise
The study highlights credit washing as “an emerging concern” that lenders must monitor closely. This tactic, which TransUnion previously reported surged 228% between January 2024 and July 2025, allows fraudsters to temporarily inflate credit scores by disputing negative but legitimate information on their reports. For example, they might falsely claim there are victims of identity fraud.
“Synthetic identity fraud, which occurs when real and fake information are combined to create a new, fictitious identity with dishonest or criminal intent, continues to drive significant financial losses,” TransUnion reported in a press release. “At the same time, however, a parallel trend — credit washing — is emerging as a complementary threat. Both tactics obscure actual consumer risk, leading to elevated losses even among credit tiers traditionally associated with lower risk.”
According to Satyan Merchant, TransUnion’s senior vice president for auto and mortgage, credit bureaus are required to suppress disputed information during investigations, creating a window where bad actors appear creditworthy on paper.
Another fraud pattern highlighted in the research is “rapid default” or “bust out” fraud — a sophisticated first-party scheme where criminals methodically build strong credit histories over years before suddenly maxing out accounts with no intention of repaying. Auto loans frequently serve as the finale in these schemes, representing the largest single fraudulent purchase before the perpetrator disappears.
ACA’s Take
ACA International recently submitted recommendations to the Federal Trade Commission to strengthen fraud mitigation, following members’ reports of a surge in alleged identity theft claims that did not match a rise in actual identity theft.
Many of the filings are incomplete, confusing, or fail to include sufficient facts to prove identity theft, said ACA CEO Scott Purcell in a letter to the FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection Director Chris Mufarrige (PDF).
Purcell stressed in the letter that ACA and its members emphatically support actual victims of identity theft and work diligently with them.
“Unfortunately, there are individuals taking advantage of the system that protects true victims, and these refinements can ensure there are resources to help those truly harmed and enhance safeguards to ensure non-victims don’t abuse the system,” Purcell said. “The FTC has a central role to play in restoring trust in the process.”
Related Content:
What the ARM Industry Can Learn from FinTech’s Fight Against Identity Fraud
ACA Submits Recommendations to Strengthen FTC Fraud Mitigation
Criminals are gaming credit reports to secure car loans they never intend to repay — and the problem has spiked 228%, TransUnion reports.





