0
Skip to content

ACA Submits Recommendations to Strengthen FTC Fraud Mitigation

Blue tech image with a lockThe recommendations address identity theft claims requirements and distinguishing disputes from identity theft.

09/08/2025 11:00 A.M.

2 minute read

ACA International recently submitted recommendations to the Federal Trade Commission to strengthen fraud mitigation after members reported a surge in alleged identity theft claims not matched by a rise in actual identity theft.

Many of the filings are incomplete, confusing, or fail to include sufficient facts to prove identity theft, said ACA CEO Scott Purcell in a letter (PDF) to the FTC’s Bureau of Consumer Protection Director Chris Mufarrige.

The filings often include unsupported assertions such as universal references to a data breach at Equifax. In many cases, internal reviews of the claims show legitimate consumer activity, with addresses and payment information matching transactions for airline tickets or rental agreements — even for accounts with long-standing payment histories — demonstrating no evidence of fraud.

The prevalence of financial services influencers, or “finfluencers,” online has amplified the problem, Purcell said.

For example, there are online templates that encourage consumers to file identity theft forms without a proper understanding of the claim, which may explain the growth in incomplete or inaccurate submissions, Purcell noted.

ACA’s recommendations to reduce abuse of complaint and dispute processes include:

  1. Require a police report to substantiate actual identity theft.
  2. Clarify consumer guidance on FTC.gov about what identity theft is — and what it is not.
  3. Distinguish disputes from identity theft clearly (a dispute is not identity theft).
  4. Update the FTC affidavit process with current forms and letters.
  5. Improve accountability by referring fraudulent filings to the Department of Justice.
  6. Authorize reasonable documentation requests for identity theft investigations.

Purcell stressed in the letter that ACA and its members emphatically support actual victims of identity theft and work diligently with them.

“Unfortunately, there are individuals taking advantage of the system that protects true victims, and these refinements can ensure there are resources to help those truly harmed and enhance safeguards to ensure non-victims don’t abuse the system,” Purcell said. “The FTC has a central role to play in restoring trust in the process.”

Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.

If you have executive leadership updates or other member news to share with ACA, contact our communications department at comm@acainternational.org. View our publications page for more information and our news submission guidelines here.

One moment please...

Share Profile

This site utilizes cookies as included in our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.