In a South Carolina district court case, the judge partially granted the defendant’s request to exclude the plaintiff’s expert testimony due to his failure to articulate concrete facts.
08/05/2024 10:00 A.M.
2 minute read
In a South Carolina district court case, Nelson v. Experian Information Solutions, Inc. (PDF), the plaintiff brought a lawsuit under the Fair Credit Reporting Act alleging that Experian incorrectly reported him as “deceased” on a Capital One tradeline, leading to a denial of housing in Texas.
As a result, the plaintiff had to move to Florida, accept a lower-paying job, and incur higher rent costs. The claims against Experian include a violation of the FCRA for failing to ensure maximum possible accuracy in credit reporting and failing to investigate inaccuracies.
Discussion
Experian filed a motion to exclude the testimony of the plaintiff’s expert, Douglas A. Hollon. The court evaluated the admissibility of Hollon’s testimony using the legal standards set forth in Federal Rule of Evidence 702 and the Daubert standard, which require expert testimony to be both relevant and reliable.
The court reviewed Hollon’s report, which concluded that Experian failed to follow reasonable procedures to ensure the maximum possible accuracy of credit reports. Additionally, Hollon criticized Experian’s reliance on data furnishers to report deceased notations and described Experian’s deceased indicator maintenance procedure as “faulty.” Hollon based these conclusions on his prior experience with Experian and its internal documents, such as the “Deceased Indicator Manual.”
Decision
The court found Hollon’s testimony on the reasonableness of Experian’s procedures inadmissible. It concluded that Hollon did not sufficiently articulate concrete facts or reliable sources to support his opinion. His reliance on personal experience and anecdotal evidence was deemed inadequate, as it lacked a clear scientific or methodological basis. Additionally, the court noted that Hollon’s opinions appeared to rely heavily on his subjective belief rather than established facts or expert methodologies, which is insufficient for expert testimony.
The court also evaluated Hollon’s opinions on the plaintiff’s damages, particularly regarding emotional and economic harm. Hollon attempted to establish his qualifications to discuss emotional damages based on his experience and training in non-psychological fields. The court excluded Hollon’s testimony on the plaintiff’s specific damages, noting that the plaintiff himself could testify about his personal experiences and the impact of the inaccuracies in his credit report.
The court further emphasized that Hollon was not qualified to offer opinions on psychological damages due to his lack of formal training in psychology. However, the court allowed Hollon to testify in general terms about the types of damages typically caused by credit report errors, provided it is relevant at trial.
Ultimately, the court granted Experian’s motion to exclude Hollon’s testimony in part, particularly regarding the reasonableness of credit reporting procedures and specific damages claims, while allowing limited testimony on general damages caused by credit report errors.
Read the order and opinion (PDF) here.
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA profile when logged in to acainternational.org.
In a South Carolina district court case, the judge partially granted the defendant’s request to exclude the plaintiff’s expert testimony due to his failure to articulate concrete facts.





