0
Skip to content

Court Orders Partial Payout in CFPB Debt Collection Lawsuit

court scale with bookThe case, which remains partly unsettled, involves the McKinnon family’s company, Northern, and their alleged illegal debt collection practices, which generated up to $1.5 million per month, in addition to efforts to fraudulently transfer property to avoid paying the family’s settlement debt.

09/26/2024 1:40 P.M.

2 minute read

In a decision (PDF) by the U.S. District Court for the Western District of New York, a case involving fraudulent debt collection and property conveyance practices reached a partial resolution.

The plaintiffs, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and the state of New York, sought summary judgment against Douglas MacKinnon and members of his family, including his wife Amy MacKinnon and his children, Mary-Kate and Matthew MacKinnon. The case stems from an initial lawsuit against Douglas MacKinnon, his company Northern, and another entity, Enhanced, for illegal debt collection practices, which generated up to $1.5 million per month.

Background

In 2016, the CFPB and the state filed a lawsuit against MacKinnon and his companies for engaging in unlawful debt collection practices. In 2019, the parties reached a settlement resulting in a $60 million judgment. However, when MacKinnon failed to meet the payment obligations, the plaintiffs pursued post-judgment discovery to locate assets. In response, they filed a new lawsuit in 2021 against MacKinnon and his family, accusing them of fraudulently transferring property to avoid satisfying the debt.

Discussion

A central issue in the current litigation concerns the transfer of MacKinnon ‘s interest in a foreclosed Erie County property to his daughter, Mary-Kate, which was considered a fraudulent conveyance. The court determined that MacKinnon transferred his share of the property without receiving fair compensation, which contributed to his insolvency. As a result, the plaintiffs argued that they were entitled to a share of the escrowed proceeds from the sale of the property.

Decision

The district court ruled in favor of the plaintiffs regarding the constructive-fraud claims against MacKinnon and Mary-Kate, ruling that the transfer of MacKinnon ‘s property interest was fraudulent.

As a result, the court directed the disbursement of $666,113 from the escrowed property proceeds, representing Mary-Kate’s share, to the CFPB and the State of New York.

Although the ruling settled constructive fraud claims, several issues in the case remain unresolved. The court did not determine the priority of other claims on the remaining escrowed funds. Claims against Douglas, Mary-Kate, and Matthew MacKinnon were dismissed as moot following the constructive-fraud ruling. However, the court granted summary judgment in favor of Amy MacKinnon, dismissing all claims against her.

In summary, the court granted partial summary judgment, awarding the plaintiffs $666,113 from the escrowed proceeds related to the fraudulent property transfer but left unresolved the broader distribution of remaining funds.

Read the decision here (PDF).

Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA profile when logged in to acainternational.org.

If you have executive leadership updates or other member news to share with ACA, contact our communications department at comm@acainternational.org. View our publications page for more information and our news submission guidelines here.

One moment please...

Share Profile

This site utilizes cookies as included in our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.