0
Skip to content

The Payday App Trap

Happy multiethnic mature couple using an ipadA new report finds that increased use of earned wage advance apps is reshaping consumers’ cash flow, and that heavy users paid $421 in loan and overdraft fees over the course of a year.

10/06/2025 1:00 P.M.

3.5 minute read

The concept sounds great: tap your phone, access tomorrow’s wages today, and sidestep an emergency. No credit check or interest, just a small tip or fee. But new data from the Center for Responsible Lending (CRL) tells a different story — one collections professionals need to understand as these apps reshape when and how consumers access cash.

After tracking more than 5,000 users of five major earned wage advance (EWA) apps over 12 months, the CRL found that borrowing isn’t occasional — it’s often compulsive and costly:

  • Average loan frequency doubled from two to four per month within a year.
  • Nearly three-quarters of users took out multiple loans within a two-week window.
  • The number of people juggling multiple EWA apps simultaneously — what researchers call “stacking” — climbed from 16% in month one to 42% by month 12.

“Rather than providing relief, these products increase the financial precarity workers are already experiencing by trapping them in a cycle of debt and reborrowing,” the report said.

The CRL used data from SaverLife, a nonprofit organization that assists low- and moderate-income workers in building savings, to analyze anonymized transactions from more than 5,000 members. Each had used at least one of five apps — Brigit, Cleo, Dave, EarnIn, or FloatMe — between January 2021 and May 2025. Researchers followed each user for 12 months after their first loan.

“Borrowing doubled over the 12 months following users’ initial activity,” the report noted, adding that “this pattern suggests borrowers are continually trying to make up for the shortfall in their paychecks caused by repeated loans and fees.”

The cost structure compounds the problem. For advances repaid within 7–14 days, the CRL calculated an average APR of 383% — nearly identical to the 391% APR typical of storefront payday loans.

Heavy users paid $421 in combined loan and overdraft fees in the first year, nearly triple the payments of moderate users and more than six times the payments of light users.

Senior researchers Christelle Bamona and Lucia Constantine, who co-authored the study, said that despite marketing claims positioning these loans as wage access rather than credit, “the essential characteristics they share with payday loans” warrant the comparison to borrowing.

Overdraft Data

When the CRL compared the three months before and after each user’s first loan, they found that overdraft incidence jumped from 9.7% to 14.1% — a 45% relative increase.

The researchers noted that “for those already struggling to make ends meet, repaying these loans can easily trigger an overdraft fee from their bank.”

Those fees further erode account balances, tighten repayment windows, and increase the likelihood that other obligations, including traditional credit accounts, will miss payment deadlines.

Stacking and the Paycheck Squeeze

The stacking trend is particularly concerning. By month 12, 42% of users were borrowing from multiple apps in the same month. Since the analysis covered only five direct-to-consumer providers, actual stacking rates may be even higher.

Each loan is typically repaid on the next payday, either via bank debit or payroll deduction. When multiple advances come due simultaneously, the resulting paycheck depletion can cascade: rent checks bounce, utility autopays fail, and credit card minimums are missed.

“Taking out multiple loans within the same pay period erodes borrowers’ paychecks and creates a cash shortfall at the end of the month, just as other bills come due,” the report warned.

What This Means for ARM Professionals

In our industry, collection professionals should keep in mind that:

  • Cash flow timing has shifted. What used to be peak liquidity — the day after payday — may now trigger multiple automatic withdrawals to EWA providers, draining accounts before other bills come due.
  • Timing matters more. If your payment cycle lands in the 48 hours after payday, you may be competing with multiple auto-debits. Days later, accounts may be empty or overdrawn.
  • Overdraft status is a leading indicator. A consumer with rising NSF fees may be cycling through advances — and may soon miss payments on traditional credit.

Read the report, “Escalating Debt: The Real Impact of Payday Loan Apps Sold as Earned Wage Advances (EWA).”

If you have executive leadership updates or other member news to share with ACA, contact our communications department at comm@acainternational.org. View our publications page for more information and our news submission guidelines here.

One moment please...

Share Profile

This site utilizes cookies as included in our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.