0
Skip to content

Policy Uncertainty Impacts Consumer Borrowing and Spending Behavior

money-phone-wallet-spending-Unfulfilled political promises can shift consumer financial habits and debt delinquency rates, a new study finds.

06/23/2026 11:00 A.M.

Anticipation of debt cancellation prompts borrowers to lower their monthly payments and increases subsequent delinquency risks, according to a National Bureau of Economic Research working paper.

A newly released working paper from the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) indicates that political promises and judicial reversals can reshape consumer financial choices long before any policy takes effect. The study examines how uncertainty surrounding federal student loan forgiveness influences household beliefs, spending and repayment habits.

Published in June 2026, the paper was authored by economists Dmitri K. Koustas, Michael Weber, and Constantine Yannelis. The researchers evaluated the aftermath of the 2022 federal student loan debt cancellation announcement, which faced immediate legal challenges and was eventually overturned by courts.

To measure the financial effects of these events, the authors used a customized information experiment embedded in consumer surveys. They linked real-time consumer expectations to credit bureau files, employment verification systems, and household consumption data.

The data revealed that optimistic beliefs about government intervention directly changed consumer cash flows. Eligible borrowers who expected their debts to be canceled reduced their regular student loan payments by an average of $40 per month.

Rather than allocating these preserved funds toward other outstanding debts or savings accounts, these consumers increased their non-durable household spending by an average of $100 per month.

Additionally, the researchers found that optimistic individuals may postpone major durable goods purchases until the legal and political uncertainty was resolved.

Similar disruptions occurred among consumers who anticipated extended freezes on their accounts. Borrowers who believed federal payment suspensions would continue made fewer total payments and cut reduced their monthly payments amounts. Once formal payment schedules resumed, these optimistic borrowers were 7.5 percentage points more likely to fall into delinquency than those with more realistic policy expectations.

The study concludes that mistaken assumptions regarding federal programs create financial friction for households. The authors calculated that the average welfare loss driven by incorrect borrower beliefs can exceed 43% of the initial loan balance. They attributed these losses to disrupted financial planning and missed opportunities for early account rehabilitation.

“This does not imply that governments should avoid communicating policy intentions,” researchers noted. “Rather, it highlights the value of clarity, credibility, and institutional feasibility in policy communication. Ambiguous or overly optimistic signals can induce households to make decisions that are privately costly and potentially destabilizing when expectations are later reversed.”

ACA’s Take

The NBER paper provides empirical backing for a common observation in the accounts receivable management industry — public confusion frequently serves as a driver for account delinquency.

As ACA International previously reported, a JPMorgan Chase Institute analysis found that post-pandemic spikes in student loan delinquency were largely tied to administrative complexities and shifting timelines rather than an absolute lack of borrower funds. In fact, that data indicated overdue borrowers were often in a stronger overall financial position than in 2019 baseline figures.

The student loan landscape is currently managing major structural overhauls driven by the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA). These legislative shifts include the introduction of the new Repayment Assistance Plan scheduled for July 1, 2026, alongside expanded opportunities for defaulted borrowers to rehabilitate their accounts twice.

Earlier this year, federal authorities adjusted timelines by pausing planned reactivations of Administrative Wage Garnishment and the Treasury Offset Program to allow for system overhauls.

ACA continues to monitor federal rulemaking to help support members’ compliance and operational plans.

Related Content from ACA:

Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA profile when logged in to acainternational.org.

If you have executive leadership updates or other member news to share with ACA, contact our communications department at comm@acainternational.org. View our publications page for more information and our news submission guidelines here.

One moment please...

Share Profile

This site utilizes cookies as included in our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.