A new study estimates that the operational and administrative costs of the federal Independent Dispute Resolution process are far higher than initially expected.
08/28/2026
The federal Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) process created under the No Surprises Act has cost health plans, providers, and federal agencies more than $22.4 billion since its implementation in 2022, according to an analysis of a Georgetown study published in Health Affairs.
The study, authored by researchers analyzing arbitration volume and administrative overhead, highlights how dispute volumes have severely stretched the system’s intended capacity. When Congress passed the No Surprises Act to protect consumers from unexpected balance bills, federal regulators initially estimated the IDR system would process roughly 17,000 disputes per year. Instead, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services reported that more than 394,000 disputes were initiated in July 2026 alone — a 24% increase from the previous month.
Four provider groups and provider representatives—mostly backed by private equity, the report notes — were behind the majority of the disputes.
“Providers also won 88% of disputes — the highest provider win rate to date — as compared to 85% in 2024 and 81% in 2023,” according to the report.
According to the analysis, the bulk of the $22.4 billion expenditure stems from administrative costs, legal fees and staff time spent navigating arbitration filings.
The research also indicates that procedural bottlenecks and ineligible filings significantly drove up these costs. A notable share of disputes entered the pipeline despite failing to meet statutory requirements, forcing arbiters and health plans to dedicate resources to noncompliant claims.
A 2025 survey from AHIP and the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association found that 39% of out-of-network disputes submitted for arbitration under the No Surprises Act were ineligible. More concerning, independent arbiters flagged only 17% of cases as improper, meaning more than half of ineligible claims resulted in binding payment determinations.
For healthcare providers and their collection partners, understanding proper IDR eligibility is critical. While arbitration can yield higher reimbursements, submitting ineligible claims contributes to system inefficiencies that ultimately impact everyone through increased premiums and administrative costs.
Federal agencies have taken notice of these financial pain points. The Departments of Health and Human Services, Labor, and the Treasury recently finalized a rule overhauling the IDR process. Measures in the updated regulations include lowering administrative dispute fees, establishing standardized claim coding to filter ineligible cases early, and introducing a centralized digital platform known as the IDR Gateway.
“We are cutting fees, improving transparency, and restoring order to a system that was overwhelmed,” said Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz. “This is about making government processes efficient, accountable, and focused on results.”
Related Content from ACA:
- Ineligible No Surprises Act Disputes Are Driving Up Health Care Costs
- Report Says Insurers are Delaying Reimbursement Under No Surprises Act
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.
A new study estimates that the operational and administrative costs of the federal Independent Dispute Resolution process are far higher than initially expected.





