New survey reveals that 39% of providers’ surprise billing disputes submitted for arbitration were found to be ineligible, contributing to billions in wasteful spending.
11/3/2025 11:00 A.M.
4.5 minute read
A significant portion of surprise billing disputes are making their way through arbitration despite being ineligible for the process, according to a recent survey from AHIP and the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association.
In the survey, health plans identified 39% of out-of-network disputes submitted for arbitration under the No Surprises Act as ineligible. More concerning, independent arbiters flagged only 17% of cases as improper, meaning more than half of ineligible claims resulted in binding payment determinations.
Under the No Surprises Act, which is designed to protect consumers from unexpected medical bills, out-of-network providers and insurers who cannot agree on a reimbursement rate must submit to binding arbitration, Arbitration Monitor notes.
The disconnect between what plans identify as ineligible versus what arbiters reject reveals a serious gap in the independent dispute resolution (IDR) process. Plans found that 33% of emergency disputes, 45% of non-emergency disputes, and 23% of air ambulance disputes failed to meet eligibility criteria — percentages more than twice as high as what arbiters determined.
Common disqualification reasons included submissions outside allowed timeframes, missing required information, cases already subject to state law resolution, and services not covered under the No Surprises Act. Last year alone, insurers paid at least 184,500 improper disputes.
Data shows the problem concentrates among a small number of provider groups. Just two private equity-backed organizations — Radiology Partners and Team Health — accounted for 43% of all resolved claims in 2023 and 2024, according to federal data analyses.
“The same private equity-backed outfits that created the surprise billing business model have turned to arbitration abuse as their new strategy to gouge consumers and employers,” said Mike Tuffin, AHIP president and CEO.
The financial implications are substantial. Georgetown University’s Center on Health Insurance Reforms estimates IDR drives $2 billion to $2.5 billion in wasteful spending annually due to high volumes of ineligible disputes and system flaws. This matters for hospital revenue cycle operations because providers win most disputes and typically receive approximately four times what insurers would have paid for in-network services.
For health care providers and their collection partners, understanding proper IDR eligibility is critical. While arbitration can yield higher reimbursements, submitting ineligible claims contributes to system inefficiencies that ultimately impact everyone through increased premiums and administrative costs.
Federal Interest
The challenges with the No Surprises Act have drawn attention from federal lawmakers and oversight agencies seeking to strengthen implementation and protect patients.
In September, Republican members of the House Ways and Means Committee sent a letter to secretaries of the Departments of Health and Human Services, Treasury, and Labor, Ways and Means Committee Republicans urging the Trump administration to continue to focus on the No Surprises Act and successfully implement the crucial patient protections provided under the law.
The committee has held hearings on challenges related to the No Surprises Act identified by patients and other stakeholders. It has identified several provisions of the law that have not been implemented or lack completion, such as:
- Federal courts found that rules proliferated by Biden-era departments were non-compliant with the No Surprises Act in four separate lawsuits.
- After five years, patients still do not consistently receive advanced explanations of benefits (AEOBs) — a key price transparency feature required by the No Surprises Act — before scheduled medical procedures.
- Federal rulemaking has created “clunky and arbitrary” obstacles that have rendered the IDR process inefficient — making patients vulnerable instead of protecting them.
“Nearly five years after the [No Surprises Act’s] passage, and spanning multiple administrations, many of these identified challenges remain unresolved … We look to this Administration to continue building on the work done by the Committee to prioritize necessary regulatory and sub-regulatory improvements so patients can realize the full potential and benefits of the [No Surprises Act],” the committee members wrote in the No Surprises Act letter to the Trump administration (PDF).
Last year, the Americans for Fair Health Care (AFHC) issued a study that found insurance companies are slow to meet the requirements of the No Surprises Act, causing delays for health care providers.
AFHC’s study of the No Surprises Act (PDF), which surveyed physicians on their experiences working with insurance providers in 2023, found that many insurers continue to fail to pay IDR awards, though the percentage declined from 52% in 2022 to 22% in the 2023.
The American Association of Healthcare Administrative Management (AAHAM) also expressed concerns with the IDR process in a 2022 position paper on the No Surprises Act and Out-of-Network billing (PDF).
“We have concerns that when an IDR entity is now involved, the final payment determination is based on only one factor as opposed to all factors that were outlined in the initial act,” AAHAM wrote. “This tips the scales in favor of the insurance payer when payment disputes are being considered.”
In 2023, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) issued a report evaluating the Independent Dispute Resolution process.
The GAO found many disputes were unresolved in the initial period after the law was enacted.
Departments within Health and Human Services, Labor and the Treasury reported that parties submitted nearly 490,000 disputes from April 2022 through June 2023. By June 2023, 61% of the disputes remained unresolved. Officials from the departments reported that they remained unresolved due to the complexity of determining whether disputes were eligible for the process.
Related Content:
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.
New survey reveals that 39% of providers’ surprise billing disputes submitted for arbitration were found to be ineligible, contributing to billions in wasteful spending.





