0
Skip to content

Nacha Seeks Input on First-Party Fraud, Proposes Clarifying ACH Recredit Timing

Nacha is asking ACH Network participants how to curb consumers falsely disputing authorized debits, and it has proposed a rule clarification that would give banks time to investigate before recrediting.

10/16/2026 10:00 A.M.

Nacha is asking all ACH Network participants for help with first-party fraud in the ACH Network. This is when consumers claim that debits they authorized were unauthorized.

The request for information and request for comment seeks feedback on the scope of the problem, which parties are best positioned to spot it, and potential ways to reduce it. It also includes a proposed rule amendment. Comments are due Dec. 11, and the proposed amendment would take effect June 18, 2027.

How the Fraud Works

In a typical case, a consumer gives a financial institution a Written Statement of Unauthorized Debit. The statement claims that the consumer did not authorize the payment. The consumer’s bank, known as the receiving depository financial institution, or RDFI, then returns the debit, usually with Return Reason Code R10. The company that started the payment loses the funds.

Nacha said anecdotal reports from financial institutions and other organizations suggest first-party fraud is increasing. It is collecting data to measure how common it is. Nacha also pointed out that the RDFI may be “in a unique position to identify first-party fraud,” since the fraud is committed by its own account holder. RDFIs are in a similar position with credit-push fraud.

For ARM companies that take payments by ACH debit, the scenario may be familiar. A consumer authorizes a payment by phone or online. Weeks later, the consumer disputes it as unauthorized and the payment is reversed. Current rules give the company collecting the payment, or its bank, few ways to respond.

Defining ‘Promptly’

The proposed amendment deals with a timing question. Under current Nacha rules, an RDFI must “promptly” recredit a consumer who submits a timely statement of unauthorized debit. The rules don’t define the term, and some institutions read it as requiring same-day reimbursement. That reading can stop them from looking into a claim first.

Jennifer Stokley, Nacha’s general counsel, took up the issue in a May 26 post. She noted that Regulation E sets its own timeline. Generally, institutions have 10 business days to investigate an error claim, or 45 days if they give provisional credit in the meantime. Stokley wrote that the lack of a definition in Nacha’s rules “should not be read as precluding an RDFI’s investigation under Reg E.”

The proposed change to Section 3.11 would make that explicit. RDFIs would not have to recredit a consumer before Regulation E requires provisional credit. For non-consumer accounts, they would not have to recredit before the end of a comparable period reasonably needed to investigate.

The proposal would not change return deadlines, and RDFIs would still have to recredit the customer before returning the entry. Nacha said no operational changes would be required. Institutions that choose to use the added time can update their procedures on their own schedule.

Proof of Authorization and Arbitration

Nacha is also gathering input on three broader topics.

The first is standardized transaction data. Nacha asks whether standard Company Entry Descriptions, authorization indicators and account-information indicators would help RDFIs judge whether a disputed debit was legitimate.

The second is challenging unauthorized returns. Under current rules, an originating institution can dishonor an unauthorized return only for administrative reasons, such as a return that arrives late or goes to the wrong place. Originators generally can’t reinitiate a debit returned as unauthorized. The one exception is an R11 return, where the debit didn’t match the authorization, and the originator corrects the error. Nacha asks whether RDFIs should consider proof of authorization when they review a consumer’s statement.

The third is Pay by Bank. Nacha said its Pay by Bank project team identified use cases that share many scenarios with first-party fraud. The team found that standardized transaction data could help participants manage risk in those payments.

As the CU Times reported, the proposals could affect how financial institutions handle dispute investigations, fraud controls and reimbursement procedures.

How to Comment

Nacha has posted a presentation, the proposed rule text and a participant survey on its rules page. It recommends that respondents review the questions first so they can gather input from across their organizations. Non-financial institutions that send or receive payments can respond as “Non-FI end users” and will see a shorter set of questions.

ACA’s Take

ACA members who collect payments by ACH debit can be directly affected when a consumer falsely claims an authorized payment was unauthorized. Members should consider responding to the survey as end users, and they should talk with their payment processors and banks about how the recredit clarification could change dispute timelines.

Related Content from ACA:

Nacha Releases Cybersecurity Tools to Target Emerging Fraud Risks

 

Remember to subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.

If you have executive leadership updates or other member news to share with ACA, contact our communications department at comm@acainternational.org. View our publications page for more information and our news submission guidelines here.

One moment please...

Share Profile

This site utilizes cookies as included in our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.