ARM industry outlook culled from recent earnings calls of three publicly traded debt collection companies: Encore, Navient and PRA Group.
08/09/2024 2:55 P.M.
8 minute read
Three of the largest publicly traded debt collection companies—Encore Capital Group, Navient and PRA Group—recently held their Q2 2024 earnings calls. As public companies with required market disclosures, their earnings calls offer an opportunity to glean macro-insights on the collections world and the economy in general.
Here are some highlights from the calls that speak to larger accounts receivable management industry trends.
Collections Environment
“In the U.S., the market for charged-off receivable portfolios continues to grow to record levels, driven by simultaneous growth in both credit card lending and the charge-off rate. As a result, we continue to see very attractive pricing and returns in the U.S.”
– Ashish Masih, president and CEO, Encore
“U.S. revolving credit has been steadily rising since early 2021. Each month, for the last three years, the U.S. Federal Reserve has reported a new record level of outstandings and it continues to grow. At the same time, since bottoming out in late 2021, the credit card charge-off rate in the U.S. has also been steadily rising and is now at its highest level in more than 10 years. Similarly, U.S. consumer credit card delinquencies, which are a leading indicator of future charge offs, also continue to rise. With both lending and the charge off rate growing simultaneously, purchasing conditions in the U.S. market remain highly favorable. We are observing not only continued strong growth in U.S. market supply, but attractive pricing as well. The most recent quarterly delinquency data reflects a typical seasonal pattern, but at meaningfully higher levels than a year ago. This data supports our expectation that 2024 will be another year of record portfolio sales by U.S. banks and credit card issuers.”
– Ashish Masih, president and CEO, Encore
“With this highly favorable purchasing environment as a backdrop, Q2 was another strong quarter of portfolio purchasing for our MCM [Midland Credit Management] business. We deployed a record $237 million dollars in the U.S. at strong returns. MCM collections in the second quarter were $397 million dollars, up 18% compared to the second quarter of 2023. Consumer payment behavior remained stable throughout the quarter.”
– Ashish Masih, president and CEO, Encore
“Global collections in the second quarter were $547 million dollars and were up 15% compared to Q2 a year ago. The past several quarters of higher portfolio purchases, particularly in the U.S., has led to meaningful growth in collections, a trend we expect to continue.”
– Ashish Masih, president and CEO, Encore
“Credit metrics in our consumer lending portfolio performed as expected with late-stage delinquency and forbearance rates relatively flat from the prior quarter at 2.2% and 1.8%, respectively, while the charge-off rate improved to 1.65% from 2.4%.”
– Joe Fisher, CFO, Navient
“In the U.S., we continue to capitalize on the strong levels of portfolio supply driven by higher industry credit card balances and rising delinquency and charge-off rates. More consumers are relying on credit to manage a higher interest rate environment and cost of living increases, which in part, has led to credit card balances growing more than 20% to $1.1 trillion as of the latest data, up from $850 million pre-pandemic. As the chart shows, there has been a long-term secular trend in industry credit card balance growth, while charge-off rates, although up from pandemic era lows, are now trending around a 10-year average. Portfolio supply is driven by both charge-off rates, as well as the absolute level of credit card balances. Based on this, we anticipate continued growth in portfolio supply for the balance of this year. Further, as there is typically a lag between sellers charging of receivables and making portfolios available for sale, we believe the U.S. supply tailwinds will extend well into 2025.”
– Vikram Atal, board member, PRA Group
“With respect to financial pressures on the U.S. consumer, we believe that certain customer segments are experiencing stress from high interest rates and continued inflation, as it is generally taking longer for some of our customers to pay off their balances. However, we are seeing significant growth in the number of committed payment plans from our customer base. We also believe our cash-generating initiatives can help mitigate pressure that might build as economic circumstances evolve. The European consumer environment reflects some of the same economic factors. However, we are also experiencing some positive trends with the proportion of paying customers continuing to remain stable. ”
-Rakesh Sehgal, chief financial officer and executive vice president, PRA Group
Legal Processes
“We expect the investments we are currently making in our U.S. legal processes to drive incremental cash collections over the next several years. For 2024, we expect a level of legal collection spending to moderate in the second half of the year. While upfront legal costs may have a negative impact on cash efficiency in the short term, given the lag in cash generation, we believe it is the appropriate action for those customers who choose not to engage with us voluntarily since it delivers optimal value over the long term.”
-Rakesh Sehgal, chief financial officer and executive vice president, PRA Group
“[O]our results reflect the increased investment we have made in our U.S. legal collection channel, which we believe positions us well for future cash generation. We invested $379 million during the quarter, with pricing remaining attractive globally. Cash collections grew 13% year over year, primarily reflecting higher recent purchases and the positive impact of cash-generating and operational initiatives in our U.S. business, along with continued cash collections growth in our European business.”
– Vikram Atal, board member, PRA Group
“[W]e are benefiting from leveraging third parties and our offshore call centers, which have helped us absorb the costs associated with a significant increase in account volumes and customer contacts. Legal collection fees increased $4 million, driven mainly by higher external legal collections within our U.S. core portfolio.”
-Rakesh Sehgal, chief financial officer and executive vice president, PRA Group
Student Loans
“During the quarter, we’re pleased we completed major steps in our first strategic action, our servicing outsourcing agreement with MOHELA. Outsourcing is a key facilitator of our ability to achieve lasting expense reduction. Nearly 900 Navient employees have now transferred to MOHELA, and our variable cost servicing model is in effect. Our more than 2 million borrowers will continue to use the same account numbers, phone numbers and payment plans. We’ve transferred several proprietary and customized technology tools and solutions to MOHELA. As we’ve previously shared with you, we will provide a limited number of services and activities under transition services agreements. We expect to complete substantially all of this initiative by the first half of next year.”
– David Yowan, CEO, Navient
“Earnest [a subsidiary of Navient] continues to efficiently generate high-quality private student loans, both refinance and in-school loans. We also continue to explore opportunities to deepen relationships with students and college grads to deliver attractive lifetime economics. We’re on track to hit our growth target for lending for the year. As is always the case, we would expect further increases in refi volume if rates drop before year-end.”
– David Yowan, CEO, Navient
“We continue to encourage borrowers who are experiencing or have historically experienced difficulty repaying their loans to take advantage of beneficial programs that are only offered to direct loan customers. Looking forward, some of the policy actions that clearly incurred consolidation have expired. The administration continues to propose and implement additional loan forgiveness and debt reduction programs on a regular and frequent basis. Consolidation requests we received have declined very recently since the expiration of some of these policies. We cannot predict whether this decline is temporary or reflects a change in pre-payment trends.”
– Joe Fisher, CFO, Navient
Operations & Management
“A new organizational structure was effective on July 1. This management structure is flatter with fewer management layers and a smaller executive team. It establishes a clear path and accountability for accomplishing the servicing and BPS transitions and expense reductions, some of which have begun to be realized. It also establishes the organization needed to manage our going-forward businesses, including substantial reductions in our corporate footprint. Our going-forward organization is preparing for an employee account that is 80% to 90% lower than when we announced the strategic actions. The MOHELA transfers that have already occurred represented roughly 20% of that workforce. Our results for the quarter reflect restructuring expenses, largely for transfers and job eliminations that are part of these organizational changes. We’re also taking steps to reduce our facilities and IT footprints. Most of our operating expense categories will be smaller, although not at the same magnitude as the employee count.”
– David Yowan, CEO, Navient
“In our U.S. call centers, we have made critical and incremental enhancements to our operating processes during the quarter, including simplifying collector workflows and rebalancing calling intensity. Ultimately, it’s a matter of increasing the number of customers we are able to reach and improving the outcomes of these conversations, and we are very encouraged by the progress thus far.”
– Vikram Atal, board member, PRA Group
“The increased level of buying in the U.S. has required an expansion of our total call center staffing by approximately 50% compared to a year ago. To counter the expense impact associated with this increase in portfolio purchases, we have focused on call center offshoring initiatives, which we initiated in the fall of 2023.”
– Vikram Atal, board member, PRA Group
Editor’s Note: All quotes taken from call transcripts provided by Yahoo! Finance and were lightly edited for clarity.
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA profile when logged in to acainternational.org to receive updates on the ACA Huddle.
ARM industry outlook culled from recent earnings calls of three publicly traded debt collection companies: Encore, Navient and PRA Group.





