The Biden-era rule, which the judge termed “illegal,” reduced credit card late fees to $8 and eliminated annual inflation adjustments.
04/16/2025 12:20 P.M.
3 minute read
On April 15, a Texas federal court vacated a 2024 Consumer Financial Protection Bureau rule that capped credit card late fees at $8 and eliminated annual inflation adjustments.
U.S. District Judge Mark Pittman in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas approved a joint motion (PDF) from a coalition of business and banking groups as well as the CFPB to throw out the rule.
After the rule was finalized in March 2024, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, American Bankers Association and others filed a lawsuit in the Northern District of Texas seeking a preliminary injunction to stop the rule from being implemented, ACA International previously reported. They argued that the CFPB exceeded its statutory authority by promulgating the rule and violated the Credit Card Accountability Responsibility and Disclosure or CARD Act of 2009.
The court granted the preliminary injunction halting the rule in May 2024.
This week, the parties agreed to a proposed consent judgment that would erase the rule entirely, without following the typical public comment process required under the Administrative Procedure Act, according to the Credit Union Times.
“If the CFPB’s rule had gone into effect, it would have resulted in more late payments, lower credit scores, higher interest rates and reduced credit access for those who need it most,” the trade groups said in an announcement. “It would have also penalized the millions of Americans who pay their credit card bills on time and reduced important incentives for consumers to manage their finances. We appreciate the CFPB’s recognition that the rule violated the law, and the Bureau’s willingness to resolve our legal challenge.”
ACA’s Take
The bureau previously sought comments on credit card fees through an advance notice of proposed rulemaking, ACA previously reported.
Congress noted in a 2022 letter (PDF) that “the CFPB broadly groups all fees associated with consumer products and services as ‘junk fees’ and does not provide any legal definition of the term or any statutory authority to define such a term.”
ACA also noted there was no research or data during the credit card late fee rulemaking process to determine the cost versus benefit if credit card holders do not make their minimum payment on time.
While not directly tied to debt collection, this rule affects the credit ecosystem in which ACA members operate. Our concern mirrors our opposition to many rules from the Chopra-led CFPB—these regulations may appear well-intentioned, but closer examination reveals their implementation would primarily harm those who most need access to reasonably-priced credit: consumers with no credit score or the lowest credit scores.
ACA continues to focus on similar regulatory overreach and lack of proper regulatory processes and stakeholder input for proposals and final rules impacting the accounts receivable management industry, such as the CFPB’s final medical debt credit reporting rule and its proposal on regulating data broker activities under the Fair Credit Reporting Act.
Similarly, for each of the CFPB’s rules and advisory opinions that ACA has opposed, we have asserted that they must conform to the Administrative Procedure Act and not violate existing laws.
Related Content from ACA International:
CFPB to Revoke Overreaching Medical Debt Advisory Opinion in ACA Advocacy Win
ACA Urges CFPB to Rescind and Review Proposed Data Broker Rule
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA profile when logged in to acainternational.org.
The Biden-era rule, which the judge termed “illegal,” reduced credit card late fees to $8 and eliminated annual inflation adjustments.





