The rule seeks to define “risks to consumers” by financial services firms and ensure consistency in its supervisory activities.
09/29/2025 2:45 P.M.
3 minute read
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau recently concluded comments on a proposed rule that would change the definitions of “risks to consumers” and “financial product or service.”
This is intended to better align the agency’s supervisory role with its legal authority and provide greater clarity on the CFPB’s supervision of the financial services industry.
The proposed rule would apply to covered persons as defined in the Consumer Financial Protection Act, who are generally engaged in offering or providing a consumer financial product or service, including debt collection and consumer reporting.
“Under the proposed rule, firms will have more clarity as to what conduct might trigger supervision, potentially lowering compliance review costs,” the CFPB reports.
Comment Summary
The bureau received 54 comment submissions on the proposed rule, ranging from consumers and consumer groups and state attorneys general to various financial services, education, and payments trade associations.
ACA International recently submitted comments (PDF) on the bureau’s advance notice of proposed rulemaking to amend definitions of larger market participants in several industries, including debt collection, and also addressed ACA’s stance on nonbank supervision.
The comments emphasize the need for a focus on consumer harm by industry bad actors, rather than legitimate businesses that are subject to repeat visits in the supervisory process — even when there are no findings of compliance concerns or violations. ACA has submitted joint comments to the CFPB, along with some of these associations, on various issues.
Following is a summary of other comments made to the CFPB:
- National Association of College and University Business Officers. The association said it appreciates the CFPB’s intent to standardize the supervisory designation process. “Clear, binding standards benefit consumers, institutions, and service providers by reducing uncertainty and compliance costs,” it said in the comments, adding that the bureau should focus on serious conduct and a consistent meaning of “risk to consumers” while preventing inadvertent supervision efforts of businesses.
- The Electronic Transactions Association. It supports the bureau’s goal to clarify the definition of consumer risk. “The newly proposed standard, focusing on conduct that presents a high likelihood of significant harm and is directly connected to the offering or provision of consumer financial products or services, is an important step toward providing regulated entities with clarity and predictability,” the association said. However, from the perspective of the payments and consumer finance industries, additional modifications to the proposal are needed to ensure the result is balanced and workable in protecting consumers and providing solutions for regulated entities.
- American Financial Services Association and American Fintech Council. The associations agreed that the bureau’s proposal is a step in the right direction and provided ideas in their comments for further clarity on defining risks to consumers. “The associations request that the CFPB revise its proposal to clarify that risk sufficient to trigger the risk-based supervisory authority must be extraordinary in nature,” their comments state, adding that the CFPB should “explain that consumer financial products and services that are offered and provided in compliance with applicable laws are presumed not to pose extraordinary risk sufficient to trigger risk-based supervisory authority.”
- American Bankers Association and Consumer Bankers Association. These associations support the bureau’s efforts to provide regulatory clarity but argue the proposal may go too far and create gaps in supervision and enforcement, and potential consumer harm. “While the other provisions of Section 1024 [of the Dodd-Frank Act] clearly define the scope of the CFPB’s supervisory authority, the nonbank risk-based supervision authority is purposefully broad,” their comments state. The associations request the CFPB maintain its current regulatory framework for nonbanks.
- State Attorneys General. New York State Attorney General Letitia James and 19 other state attorneys general oppose the bureau’s proposed rule due to the evolution and growth of digital and financial services available to consumers, which necessitate supervision. “The CFPB’s ability to designate nonbanks for supervision is a key tool to protect consumers and promote fair and transparent consumer financial markets,” the attorneys general state in their comments. “Yet in the face of rapidly growing and evolving markets that increasingly touch the financial lives of American consumers every day, the bureau is now proposing a rule that will impose artificial and arbitrary limits on its oversight of the entities that are responsible for digital payments.”
How Did We Get Here?
According to the CFPA, the bureau can supervise a nonbank company if it has good reason to believe that the company’s actions pose a risk to consumers. Before beginning supervision, the bureau must first notify the company and provide it with a reasonable opportunity to respond.
To date, the bureau has issued orders on individual cases to investigate companies that may pose risks to consumers.
Several concerns about this process prompted the bureau to issue the proposed rule:
- The ad hoc nature of individual orders creates a danger that the bureau’s application of “risks to consumers” may not be consistent between orders.
- Because the applicability of the precedents in past orders to new contexts can be unclear, and also because the agency may depart from an existing precedent in a later case, the status quo creates uncertainty for institutions facing potential designation about what standard the bureau will apply to their case.
- Without a binding framework on the meaning of “risks to consumers,” the bureau may not conform to the best reading of section 1024(a)(1)(C) of the CFPA in individual cases.
The goal of the proposed rule is to solve these problems by establishing a clear and predictable standard for the bureau, as stated in the Federal Register notice.
It also seeks to address Congress’ expectations for bureau supervision.
The CFPB highlighted in the proposed rule that “Congress would not have expected it to expend its supervisory resources on issues that are speculative in likelihood or trivial in impact. Although some prior orders have adopted a broad approach to the phrase ‘risks to consumers’ under the CFPA, asserting that it can include even immaterial potential harms, the bureau proposes to reconsider this approach.”
In short, the CFPA indicates that Congress intended the bureau to be primarily focused on serious conduct.
The bureau proposes that the final rule take effect 30 days after publication in the Federal Register. However, if the final rule is determined to be a “major rule” as defined in the Congressional Review Act, it proposes for it to take effect 60 days after publication in the Federal Register.
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.
The rule seeks to define “risks to consumers” by financial services firms and ensure consistency in its supervisory activities.





