0
Skip to content

Identity Theft Victims Wait Nearly Two Years for IRS Case Resolution

ai, fraud, scamTax-related fraud claims quadrupled in 2021, creating a backlog that still persists. The IRS acknowledges that process improvements are necessary.

09/25/2026 5:00 P.M.

Consumers asserting tax-related identity theft waited an average of 20 months for the Internal Revenue Service to process their cases, according to a report released by the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration (TIGTA).

TIGTA’s findings show that case receipts in the agency’s Identity Theft Victim Assistance (IDTVA) unit nearly quadrupled during fiscal year 2021 amid pandemic-related disruption. High volumes have persisted due to the increasing sophistication and frequency of tax fraud operations.

Although the IRS sets an internal target of resolving identity theft claims within 120 calendar days of receipt, TIGTA’s review of closed cases revealed a different reality. In a sample of 114 cases closed during fiscal year 2023, only four met the 120-day standard, with the average processing time reaching 655 calendar days. Most of this time was spent waiting for an assistor to be available to work on the case.

These delays frustrate and burden taxpayers while they wait to receive their refunds, according to the TIGTA report. During that period, they often don’t hear anything from the IRS about the status of their case and aren’t informed of the approximate 20-month case processing wait time.

“When taxpayers do not receive updates from the IRS, they may call the toll-free lines seeking an update,” the report notes. “We identified 32 taxpayers from our sample cases that called the IRS to discuss their IDT cases. Some of these taxpayers made anywhere from 21 to 57 phone calls to the IRS.”

The delays also carry a direct cost to the federal government.

“Our analysis of identity theft cases closed from FY 2023 through FY 2025 identified that the IRS paid approximately $124.2 million in interest on the delayed refunds,” according to the TIGTA.

Despite the initial delays in case assignment, TIGTA observed that resolution occurs quickly once an assistor begins active work on a file. The report noted that 54% of self-reported identity theft cases were resolved within 30 days of being assigned to an IRS assistor, with a small percentage processed on the same day.

TIGTA recommended that the IRS refine its intake screening processes to evaluate case complexity earlier, accelerate assignments to support staff and implement procedures for providing identity theft acknowledgment letters to all affected taxpayers.

In response, the IRS said it will assess the feasibility of using artificial intelligence for case screening rather than reallocating fully trained identity theft personnel from detailed casework.

“We will continue working to reduce both the backlog and the time taxpayers wait,” said Kenneth Corbin, chief of the IRS taxpayer service division.

ACA’s Take

Receivables management professionals play a crucial role in the identity theft resolution process. Often, the first notice consumers receive that they have fallen victim to identity theft is a collection call about a debt they were not aware of. This early detection allows victims to take swift action.

When credible indicators of identity theft are present, continuing collection activity without review can increase risk. Best practices suggest pausing collection efforts while a claim is evaluated, especially when a consumer provides an identity theft report from IdentityTheft.gov — which businesses can use as documentation that fraud has been reported to the FTC.

Pausing activity does not mean accepting every claim at face value, but it does allow agencies to avoid actions that could later be challenged as unreasonable or unfair under federal or state laws. In some states, receiving certain documentation from a consumer can trigger specific legal obligations. As a result, it is important for agencies to understand and follow the requirements in the states where they operate.

Additionally, while legitimate identity theft requires immediate action, industry professionals also have to remain vigilant against fraudulent dispute tactics. According to a Federal Trade Commission consumer alert, online “finfluencers” are coaching followers on a so-called “secret hack” to instantly wipe negative marks from their credit reports. The influencers say the fix is to file a false identity theft report at IdentityTheft.gov in an attempt to trigger the automatic removal of legitimate debts.

The FTC strongly warns against following this advice. “Filing a false identity theft report may leave you worse off — and it’s a crime that could get you a fine, imprisonment, or both,” the consumer alert states.

ACA has also highlighted these trends — part of a broader rise in identity theft-related fraud activity — in fraud mitigation recommendations to the FTC.

Related Content from ACA:

 

Remember to subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.

If you have executive leadership updates or other member news to share with ACA, contact our communications department at comm@acainternational.org. View our publications page for more information and our news submission guidelines here.

One moment please...

Share Profile

This site utilizes cookies as included in our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.