0
Skip to content

House Financial Services Committee Votes to Overhaul CFPB Oversight and Enforcement

The House Financial Services Committee voted 28–21 along party lines to advance H.R. 10184, a comprehensive reform package that would shift the CFPB to congressional appropriations, establish a dedicated Inspector General, and introduce strict cost-benefit guardrails. The bill now heads to the full House floor following the midterm recess.

09/18/2026 12:00 P.M.

The House Financial Services Committee voted along party lines (28–21) to favorably report H.R. 10184, the Consumer Financial Protection Accountability and Reform Act of 2026, out of committee during a markup hearing on Sept. 16, 2026.

Introduced by Financial Institutions Subcommittee Chairman Andy Barr, R-Ky., alongside Committee Chairman French Hill, R-Ark., the comprehensive legislation aims to restructure the CFPB’s leadership, funding, and enforcement authorities.

During the markup, Barr said the legislation restores “basic balance” to the CFPB by protecting consumers and preserving access to credit while respecting the role of the states and other prudential regulators.

Most importantly, Barr said, it puts an “extraordinarily powerful” federal agency under congressional control.

In his opening remarks, Hill stressed that H.R. 10184 creates durable guardrails to make the CFPB more transparent and accountable, keeping its core focus on consumer protection while promoting market competition, innovation, and access to affordable credit.

“Protecting consumers also means ensuring that the government itself follows the law, respects due process, and remains accountable,” Hill said. “That is the goal of H.R. 10184.”

Core Structural Reforms in H.R. 10184 include:

  • Appropriations Control: Subjects the CFPB’s budget to annual congressional approval instead of Federal Reserve funding.
  • Independent Oversight: Creates a Senate-confirmed Inspector General dedicated exclusively to the bureau.
  • Regulatory Checks: Requires cost-benefit analyses and subjects major rules to banking regulator review.
  • Innovation & Access: Cuts duplicate exams to boost competition, lower costs, and expand credit access.
  • Predictable Supervision: Replaces regulation-by-enforcement with transparent standards, fair penalties, and compliance incentives.

Overall, Barr framed the legislative package as a long-overdue restoration of constitutional balance, noting that consumer protection and credit access are complementary goals that require congressional oversight rather than “administrative whiplash.”

U.S. Rep. Dan Meuser, R-Pa., chairman of the House Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, shared his support for the legislation. He said that bringing the bureau under congressional funding oversight and cost-benefit guardrails curbs administrative overreach while protecting local businesses.

Opponents of the legislation focused on its impact on the CFPB’s oversight authority.

U.S. Rep. Maxine Waters, D-Calif., ranking member of the committee, warned that capping civil money penalties, altering the public consumer complaint database, and limiting enforcement powers would undermine consumer relief and support predatory lenders.

Debate Over Civil Investigative Demand Reform

A key component of the broader CFPB reform push during the markup included debate on H.R. 1653, the Civil Investigative Demand (CID) Reform Act of 2025, which applies due process guardrails to bureau investigations.

Barr, who also sponsors the CID legislation, argued that under recent leadership, the bureau engaged in “fishing expeditions” — forcing compliant businesses to endure costly record requests and depositions without being notified of specific allegations. Barr emphasized that requiring CIDs to have a grounded factual basis and defined scope does not impede lawful investigations but rather enhances the credibility and due process of the bureau’s work.

U.S. Rep. Sylvia Garcia, D-Texas, opposed the CID legislation, arguing that narrowing demand parameters would tip off bad actors and hinder the CFPB’s ability to hold wrongdoers accountable.

Barr responded that the goal of the legislation is not to alert bad actors, but to help the government identify its allegations when it submits a CID to a business.

He stressed that it establishes basic guardrails around alleged wrongdoing.

The legislation doesn’t restrict the bureau’s power to conduct lawful investigations — it ensures those inquiries follow clear rules, Barr said.

What’s Next?

H.R. 10184 now moves to the full House floor for consideration.

The House is in recess until after the November 2026 midterm elections.

House passage of H.R. 10184 would shift the debate over CFPB funding and other reforms to the Senate and White House.

ACA International recently offered feedback on the committee’s discussion draft of the legislation, highlighting that a lack of bureau accountability and reform has led to excessive over-regulation, a key driver of consumer inflation, while emphasizing the essential economic role the credit and collection industry plays for both consumers and businesses.

If enacted, the legislation could fundamentally reshape the regulatory landscape for debt collection agencies, asset buyers, and collection law firms by directly relieving several long-standing operational pain points.

ACA has emphasized to lawmakers that it’s time for Congress to act on CFPB reform. A more transparent, predictable CFPB that does not undergo extreme political swings with each election will ultimately benefit ACA members, consumers, and the broader economy.

Related Content from ACA:

 

Remember to subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.

If you have executive leadership updates or other member news to share with ACA, contact our communications department at comm@acainternational.org. View our publications page for more information and our news submission guidelines here.

One moment please...

Share Profile

This site utilizes cookies as included in our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.