Is Buy Now, Pay Later harmful to consumers? A new report from the CFPB says it’s not.
06/16/2025 2:15 P.M.
1.5 minute read
The pros and cons of Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) services continue to make headlines. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau recently withdrew a rule regulating BNPL, sparking a clash between the agency and consumer advocacy groups.
Last week, CFPB researchers released a working paper suggesting that BNPL services are not harmful to consumers. The study, conducted by economists Cortnie Shupe and Giordano Palloni, analyzed data from the six largest BNPL companies over several years. The findings indicated minimal negative impacts on consumers using BNPL, contradicting a previous CFPB study from January 2025 that raised concerns about debt accumulation among BNPL users.
The January study found that 63% of BNPL users took out multiple types of loans, and 33% borrowed from multiple BNPL providers simultaneously. This raised concerns about loan-stacking and potential financial distress. However, the June study showed that BNPL users generally do not increase their non-BNPL debt and are likely to repay BNPL providers in full.
“BNPL is a smarter, more transparent alternative to high-interest credit cards,” David Sykes, chief commercial officer for Klarna, told Payments Dive.
This sentiment is echoed by industry supporters who argue that the June study validates the safety of BNPL services.
Despite the positive findings from the June study, consumer advocates remain skeptical, the Payments Dive article notes, insisting that BNPL be tightly regulated to prevent potential consumer harm.
“Consumer advocates who reviewed both studies said that neither supports the notion that buy now, pay later products make credit more accessible to consumers with poor credit history or no credit score, an argument often put forth by BNPL companies,” according to the article.
Related Content from ACA International:
Is Buy Now, Pay Later harmful to consumers? A new report from the CFPB says it’s not.





