A non-party entity received additional subpoenas in a case against TransUnion regarding alleged improper furnishing of consumer reports to third parties.
12/05/2024 3:40 P.M.
1.5 minute read
In a recent development in a Fair Credit Reporting Act case, a court has partially granted and partially denied a motion to quash subpoenas issued to Portfolio Recovery Associates, LLC (PRA), a non-party defendant.
The case centers on allegations that TransUnion, in a previously related case (PDF), improperly furnished consumer reports to third parties, including PRA, in violation of the FCRA.
Background
The plaintiff, representing a putative class of consumers, accused TransUnion of unlawfully sharing consumer reports with third parties such as PRA, thereby breaching the FCRA. The court previously ordered PRA to produce data from Jan. 20, 2021, to April 30, 2023, and to include additional data from Jan.1, 2020. Depositions of PRA employees were scheduled for September 2024.
PRA challenged the subpoenas for document production and depositions, arguing undue burden and requesting more time to comply. The motion was reviewed under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 26(b)(1) and 45(d)(3)(A)(iv), which governs discovery relevance, proportionality, and the burden on non-parties.
Discussion
The court denied PRA’s motion to quash depositions for three employees: Krishna Bhalasubramanyam, James Bostwick, and Susan Guevara.
PRA contended that employee David Lomberk’s testimony was sufficient and additional information could come from TransUnion. However, the court found those three individuals possessed unique, relevant knowledge not covered by Lomberk’s testimony. It emphasized PRA’s obligation to provide knowledgeable witnesses and determined the deposition burden was not undue given the value of the information.
Decision
The court extended PRA’s document production deadline but denied the motion to quash the deposition subpoenas. It affirmed the depositions’ relevance and trusted plaintiff’s counsel to conduct them efficiently, with potential case deadline modifications if needed.
ACA’s Take
This decision highlights courts’ careful approach to discovery disputes with non-party entities, suggesting debt collectors should review their document retention policies accordingly.
A non-party entity received additional subpoenas in a case against TransUnion regarding alleged improper furnishing of consumer reports to third parties.





