A Utah district court rejected the bureau’s claim that the program was a credit arrangement, siding with Snap Finance and denying the CFPB’s attempts at regulation.
08/09/2024 2:25 P.M.
3 minute read
In a recent legal decision, a U.S. district court dismissed the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s complaint against Snap Finance LLC regarding its lease-to-own program that ran from 2017 to 2020, according to a summary from ACA International member Barron & Newburger, P.C.
The CFPB’s lawsuit, filed in July 2023, alleged that Snap Finance (Snap RTO LLC, Snap Second Look LLC, Snap U.S. Holdings LLC, and Snap Financial Holdings LLC— collectively known as Snap) misled consumers with its “100-Day Cash Payoff” advertising, claiming that it misrepresented the terms and conditions of the lease agreements, thereby violating federal law.
The court, however, sided with Snap Finance, rejecting the CFPB’s interpretation of the program as a credit arrangement.
Background
The CFPB’s complaint comprised of 10 counts against Snap, alleging violations of several federal laws. The core of the CFPB’s argument was that Snap’s advertising led consumers to believe that the 100-day payoff option was the default payment plan, when in reality, consumers had to actively opt in to benefit from this offer. The bureau accused Snap of misleading consumers, interfering with their understanding of the lease terms, and misrepresenting payment obligations and consumer rights.
The CFPB’s claims included violations of the Consumer Financial Protection Act (CFPA), the Electronic Fund Transfer Act (EFTA) and Regulation E, the Truth in Lending Act (TILA) and Regulation Z, and the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and Regulation V.
Specifically, the CFPB alleged that Snap conditioned consumer repayments on the preauthorization of automated clearing house transactions, failed to provide necessary disclosures, misrepresented consumers’ rights to terminate agreements, and threatened consumers with false intentions regarding property repossession.
Snap, in response, filed a motion to dismiss the CFPB’s complaint, arguing that its lease agreements did not constitute credit arrangements, according to Barron & Newburger. Snap contended that the lease did not grant consumers the right to defer payment of a debt or purchase property on deferred payment terms.
Decision
The court upheld Snap’s argument, rejecting the CFPB’s broad interpretation of “credit” as inconsistent with existing legal definitions. It dismissed counts one through eight of the CFPB’s complaint.
The court highlighted that the CFPB’s arguments relied on the practical operation of the lease agreements rather than their formal terms. The bureau claimed that Snap’s practices effectively decoupled payment from possession, akin to a credit arrangement. However, the court found that Snap’s decision not to repossess property from delinquent consumers did not equate to granting consumers a right to defer payment.
Additionally, the court emphasized that Snap’s lease agreements did not meet the statutory definition of credit because they did not provide consumers with any right to defer payments. While the CFPB argued that consumers might have believed they were entering credit arrangements, the court maintained that the actual service provided by Snap was not credit.
Consequently, the court found Snap’s lease-to-own agreements were not subject to the provisions of the CFPA, and the bureau’s attempt to impose such regulations was unwarranted.
This decision is a notable setback for the CFPB, challenging its efforts to regulate lease-to-own programs as credit arrangements based on consumer perceptions rather than contractual terms, according to Barron & Newburger. Additionally, while the court dismissed Snap’s argument for a two-year statute of limitations on the FCRA claims, it affirmed a three-year statute of limitations, providing clarity on the timeframe for such claims.
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA profile when logged in to acainternational.org.
A Utah district court rejected the bureau’s claim that the program was a credit arrangement, siding with Snap Finance and denying the CFPB’s attempts at regulation.





