The decision indicates that courts are scrutinizing plaintiffs’ claims and not turning a blind eye to improper filing motives.
08/08/2024 2:25 P.M.
1.5 minute read
A North Carolina district court rejected a plaintiff’s motion to strike an affirmative defense, warning it will sanction the consumer under Rule 11 for abuse of court processes if he continues to file similar lawsuits.
On Jan. 2, 2024, Brenton Walker mailed a dispute letter to the collection agency contesting a debt owed to First Access Bank of Missouri. Walker stated in the letter that the agency should contact him only via email. Despite this instruction, the agency sent him a letter in response to the dispute letter.
The consumer sued the debt collector, but the court noted that his sole argument is that the pleading standards enunciated in Ashcroft v. Iqbal apply to affirmative defenses. The court said the consumer failed to cite “any binding authority for this proposition, and the court’s research has revealed none.”
Also, not only did the consumer file the same identical complaint twice on the case’s electronic docket, but his suit also relied on mostly unpublished district court opinions from other circuits.
In its brief, the defendant points to several filings from the plaintiff in similar cases identical to the instant motion, and “suggests that [the] plaintiff obtained it from an outside party, who wrote it as a form motion to help parties vexatiously increase litigation costs.”
The court seemed to agree with this assertion, noting that it “reviewed these other dockets and filings, and they are indeed identical in all material respects to the instant motion, including their reliance on the cases noted above in courts outside the Fifth, Sixth, and Tenth Circuits, identical headings, and other telltale similarities. At this point, the court merely notes these similarities and takes no other action, given the limited record and that defendant requests only the denial of the motion. But the court will view future similar maneuvers, which suggest an improper filing motive, with skepticism, and may order the filing party to show cause why they should not be sanctioned under Rule 11.” [Emphasis added.]
Read Brenton Walker v. LVNV Funding LLC, d/b/a Resurgent Capital Services LP (PDF).
The decision indicates that courts are scrutinizing plaintiffs’ claims and not turning a blind eye to improper filing motives.





