The CFPB proposed to rescind its rule requiring nonbanks to report certain enforcement actions to the database. ACA and similar groups have consistently urged the CFPB to eliminate this registry while others say there will be costs to consumers without it.
06/17/2025 2:15 P.M.
3 minute read
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau recently closed comments on a proposal to rescind its 2024 rule that established a registry tracking enforcement actions against nonbank entities, including debt collectors, at local, state and federal levels.
The rule (PDF) requires nonbank entities, including debt collectors, to register when they are subject to enforcement actions, ACA International previously reported.
In a notice for public comment published in the Federal Register, the bureau proposes rescinding the rule due to its costs and requirements that are already covered by other federal regulators as well as in the states.
The bureau received 16 comments on the proposal to rescind the rule.
The rule requires certain nonbank covered persons to report specific information to the bureau’s registry. These entities, which provide consumer financial products or services but are not classified as banks, must comply with this requirement if they are subject to final public orders. The entities must report the existence of these orders and any related information.
ACA has consistently urged the CFPB to eliminate this registry, including in May 2025 comments (PDF) to the Office of Management and Budget regarding deregulation.
The CFPB has already announced it would not prioritize enforcement or supervision actions related to the nonbank registry.
ACA’s initial comments (PDF) on the proposed registry from March 2023 stated that the CFPB should work collaboratively with companies toward shared goals for the best consumer outcomes, rather than treating them as adversities that are guilty until proven innocent.
Comment Summary
Stakeholder feedback on rescinding the rule showed a mix of support and opposition from trade groups and consumer advocates, similar to the previous comment periods but at a smaller scale.
Following is a summary of some of the comments.
Conference of State Bank Supervisors
The Conference of State Bank Supervisors (CSBS), representing state regulators, said in comments that rescinding the rule is appropriate for the following reasons:
- “Robust supervision and existing enforcement authorities, at the state and federal levels, are more than sufficient to address potential ‘repeat offenders.’
- The rule creates a costly reporting, registration and compliance regime—irrespective of actual consumer harm—simply to republish information that is already publicly available.
- The rule unlawfully encroaches on state authority, most egregiously by requiring certain nonbanks to annually attest to the CFPB that they are complying with state orders.”
CSBS previously said in comments on the rule during the proposal stages that it is misguided because state regulators already report public enforcement actions, among other reasons.
Small Business Administration Office of Advocacy
The Office of Advocacy also previously commented on the rule and expressed concern with its “adverse economic impact on small entities.”
It encouraged the CFPB to review less burdensome alternatives and supported the current proposal to rescind the rule.
In new comments filed this month, the office also recommends the CFPB identify the number of small entities impacted by the rescission and the potential cost savings to small entities in the final rule.
Based on its estimates from CFPB and Census Bureau data, the office finds rescinding the rule could have saved affected small entities roughly $28.7 to $143.4 million or more in compliance costs over the next 10 years.
Online Lenders Alliance
The Online Lenders Alliance, which includes online lenders, vendors, service providers and credit reporting agencies, previously raised “serious concerns” about the proposed rule as a beneficial tool to trial attorneys rather than consumers and regulators.
The alliance reiterated those concerns in new comments, which note the rule duplicates state efforts and “provides a lever for the CFPB to enforce state and local orders to which it was never a party, and which are premised on violations of state laws and local ordinances that the CFPB has no authority to enforce.”
Americans for Financial Reform Education Fund
The organization, which represents more than 200 civil rights, consumer, labor, investor, faith-based and civic and community groups, supported the proposed rule for a nonbank registry.
“A centralized public repository of nonbank enforcement and agency orders will greatly help state and federal regulators, consumer advocates, and the public identify repeat offenders and more effectively spot patterns and practices of misconduct,” it said in comments filed last week.
Overall, they said the registry helps the CFPB fulfill its congressional mandate to monitor risks in the consumer financial marketplace.
Better Markets Inc.
The organization, founded after the 2008 financial crisis to promote the public interest in financial markets, opposed rescinding the rule and eliminating the nonbank registry for its costs on consumers.
“These costs would arise from reduced market transparency, increased risk of consumer harm from repeat offenders, and the weakening of regulatory deterrence and accountability mechanisms, among other harms,” according to the comments.
The group says there is more consumer risk with the increase in nonbanks in the lending marketplace.
What’s Next?
If finalized, the proposed rule would take effect immediately upon publication in the Federal Register and would rescind all information requirements for the registry.
“Regulated entities would benefit from the rescission becoming effective immediately upon publication of a final rule and doing so would not be disruptive to their business operations,” according to the CFPB.
A summary of the proposed rule to remove the database is available here: https://www.regulations.gov/ docket/ CFPB-2025-0011.
The CFPB is expected to issue additional proposed rules to rescind or revise regulations from the prior administration, according to a client alert from Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck LLP.
Brownstein also reports the CFPB submitted five proposed regulatory actions to the Office of Management and Budget’s Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs for review.
Related Content from ACA International:
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.
The CFPB proposed to rescind its rule requiring nonbanks to report certain enforcement actions to the database. ACA and similar groups have consistently urged the CFPB to eliminate this registry while others say there will be costs to consumers without it.





