The bureau’s latest biennial review of the consumer credit market reveals that rising interest rates and record-high balances are placing pressure on lower-score borrowers.
01/08/2026 2:00 P.M.
4.5 minute read
The U.S. economic narrative for 2026 is currently a tale of two balance sheets. On one hand, top-line figures show a surprising resilience; on the other, regulatory reports indicate that the wellness check for the average consumer is returning some concerning results.
According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s seventh biennial review of the consumer credit market report to Congress, the composition of U.S. debt has undergone a fundamental shift. For the first time in recent years, banking and financial obligations — mostly credit card debt — represent the largest share of third-party collection tradelines.
This shift is partly an accounting byproduct. Starting in 2023, the three major credit bureaus (Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion) began removing medical collections of $500 or less from credit reports. With that data largely removed, credit card debt has moved to the forefront, now accounting for 32% of all third-party collections.
Balances and the Burden of Interest
Credit card debt exceeded $1.2 trillion in 2024, with the average monthly balance per cardholder climbing to approximately $5,300. The report also noted that consumers were assessed $160 billion in interest charges in 2024, a massive jump from the $105 billion reported in 2022.
The CFPB attributes this spike to three primary factors:
- Higher average annual percentage rates (APRs) driven by changes to the prime rate.
- A 9.5% increase in the total number of cardholders.
- An 18% increase in average monthly balances.
The report notes a shift in consumer behavior: the share of cardholders making only the minimum payment rose to 15% for general-purpose cards and 20% for private-label cards.
“The increase was largest for cardholders with subprime, near-prime, and prime credit scores,” the CFPB said, indicating that financial strain is moving up the credit spectrum.
The Math of Delinquency
For accounts receivable management professionals, the concern isn’t just the volume of debt, but the cost and the “cure.” APRs reached 25.2% for general-purpose cards and a staggering 31.3% for private-label cards — the highest levels the CFPB has recorded since 2015.
Additionally, data from large issuers suggests a weakening in “cure rates” — the frequency with which delinquent accounts are brought current before reaching the 180-day charge-off mark. The average cure rate dropped to 47.6% in 2024, down from 54.7% in 2022. Simultaneously, charge-off rates climbed to 8.8%, a significant jump from the 5.2% seen just two years prior.
Why National Averages Deceive
While these national figures provide a baseline, economist Chris Kuehl, managing director of Armada CI, argues that ARM leaders must look closer to home. Speaking at a recent ACA Super Huddle, Kuehl noted that the U.S. GDP is larger than the combined GDPs of China, Japan, Germany, and the UK.
“Every single state in the country corresponds to a country when it comes to GDP,” Kuehl said.
He emphasized that a collector in North Dakota, where unemployment sits around 2.2%, faces a different reality than one in New Jersey. In high-growth states, Kuehl suggests there is “less of an excuse to be in economic distress,” whereas slower regions require a more nuanced evaluation of consumer hardship.
Emerging Trouble Spots: Auto and the “Bottom Third”
Kuehl identified two primary areas of concern for 2026:
- Auto Loans: Unlike the 2008 mortgage crisis, today’s pressure is in the driveway. Kuehl noted that many consumers overbought vehicles beyond their means. Reports of consumers “tossing the keys on the desk” at dealerships are becoming more common as they abandon loans they can no longer sustain.
- The Income Divide: Kuehl segmented the consumer base into three tiers. The upper third ($100,000+) is “spending like there’s no tomorrow,” while the bottom third ($50,000 or less) is using credit cards specifically to fund daily necessities.
This data correlates with the CFPB’s findings: rising interest rates and record-high balances are placing disproportionate pressure on lower-score borrowers. While real disposable income has returned to “normal” levels for some, it is not evenly distributed.
Communication Trends: Digital Saturation and Lower Engagement
Despite the proliferation of digital tools, reaching consumers remains a hurdle. The CFPB’s survey data found that while nearly 89% of delinquent accounts are now email-eligible, getting a consumer to actually open those emails is a different story. The “click-open” rate fell to 31.9% in 2024, a decrease from 36.3% in 2022.
Text messaging, once viewed as the next frontier for high engagement, has stabilized. Eligibility for SMS contact has stalled at approximately 59% of accounts, and engagement rates through this channel actually saw a slight dip to 54.2%.
Additionally, CFPB data indicates that in 2024, issuers averaged 1.2 telephone contact attempts per day — far below the three-to-four-call daily caps many institutions have in place.
Disputes and Digital Shifts
A notable area of friction identified in the report is the rise in transaction disputes. Cardholders disputed $9.8 billion in charges in 2024. Interestingly, 40% of general-purpose card disputes stemmed from canceled recurring transactions, such as “subscriptions, membership fees, and utility bills.”
The CFPB also highlighted the role of artificial intelligence in the market. While AI is being used to expand access to credit through alternative data, like cash-flow analysis, it is also “accelerating the incidence and seriousness of payments-related fraud.”
Related Resources From ACA:
- CFPB Releases Data Archives from Surveys on Consumers’ Financial Status
- From the Web: Rising Inflation, Debt Call for Adaptable Collection Approaches
- Beyond the Gloom: Economist Chris Kuehl’s 2025–26 Outlook for ARM Professionals
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.





