The rule restores past bureau practices to treat supervisory designation proceedings as confidential.
10/27/2025 2:30 P.M.
2 minute read
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s final rule on supervisory designation procedures for nonbanks is in effect.
The final rule updates procedures for designating nonbanks for CFPB supervision and enhancing confidentiality in those proceedings.
This restores the bureau’s 2013 policy of treating “decisions and orders in supervisory designation proceedings as confidential supervisory information.”
After reviewing comments on the supervisory designation rules, the bureau concluded that fear of reputational damage from disclosure could prompt firms to accept unwarranted supervision and therefore rescinded amendments to the 2013 policy that made supervisory designation proceedings public.
The final rule also reinstates the requirement that the director receive recommended determinations in supervisory proceedings before making a final decision.
The bureau believes the “recommended determination will enhance the bureau’s deliberative process by providing the director with additional analysis,” according to the final rule.
How Did We Get Here?
In April and November 2022, and again in April 2024, the bureau amended the 2013 supervisory designation procedures. The most significant change authorized the CFPB director to publicly release final decisions and orders designating companies for supervision.
In May 2025, the bureau requested public comments on rescinding the 2022 and 2024 rules and reinstating the 2013 rule.
Several commenters during the 2022 rulemaking expressed concerns about the bureau’s process for the supervisory designation proceedings.
ACA International said in 2022 comments on the supervisory designation rule (PDF) that it was unaware of any other financial regulator with such broad authority to publicly target certain companies using confidential supervisory information and that the CFPB’s proposal was a departure from processes at other federal banking regulators.
“The possibility of naming companies on a public website through the process the CFPB outlines in the name of transparency also conflicts with longstanding policies that several other financial regulators have for guarding confidential information garnered in the supervision process,” ACA said.
The bureau received eight responses to the May 2025 request for comment on the previous supervisory designation proceedings. After considering the comments, the bureau decided to rescind the rules from 2022 and 2024, except for some limited process adjustments in the 2024 rule.
“In the [b]ureau’s experience, the financial services industry is highly focused on reputational concerns. The public interest is not served if the bureau designated entities that ought not be designated but accede to designation out of fear of reputational harm,” it states in the final rule.
Overall, the final rule clarifies the process and confidentiality parameters for bringing nonbanks (including larger participants in collections or related services) under CFPB supervisory oversight. Accounts receivable management firms, debt buyers, servicers, and data/AI vendors supporting collection workflows should reassess supervisory exposure and readiness.
The bureau is also focusing on nonbank supervision standards through a proposed rule that would change the definitions of “risks to consumers” and “financial product or service.”
This is intended to better align the agency’s supervisory role with its legal authority and provide greater clarity on the CFPB’s supervision of the financial services industry, ACA International previously reported.
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.
The rule restores past bureau practices to treat supervisory designation proceedings as confidential.





