0
Skip to content

Study Finds YouTube Leads Social Media Platforms in Misleading Financial Advice

money-phone-wallet-spending-Only 2.2% of content creators are qualified to give financial advice, yet misleading content gets more engagement than accurate advice.

09/30/2026 1:30 P.M.

An analysis by legal technology firm Legalaes found that nearly 29% of financial and investment videos across major social media platforms contain misleading information, with YouTube posting the highest concentration of flawed content.

“The public is consuming financial content on social media in record numbers. Viewers are watching, reacting, and frequently acting on the advice offered, which is concerning because the data show nearly three in 10 of these videos are misleading,” according to the study.

Legalaes evaluated 1,764 videos across TikTok, Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook to examine the quality and risk profile of financial advice shared by social media content creators. Researchers determined that 41.8% of sampled YouTube videos contained misleading information. Instagram followed at 26.8%, while Facebook and TikTok recorded misleading content rates of 23.3% and 23%, respectively.

Despite hosting the highest percentage of misleading videos, YouTube also held the highest share of accurate financial content at 38.3%, compared to 36.3% on TikTok, 32% on Instagram, and 28% on Facebook.

“Educational content grounded in established investment principles and sound financial advice is misleading if it also promotes a paid product or service, suggests specific return/outcome, recommends a specific investment amount, or uses guaranteed-return language,” according to the study.

Researchers noted that YouTube’s higher concentration of credentialed creators — 5.1% compared to less than 2% on other platforms — contributes to its higher volume of accurate guidance. However, YouTube creators were also significantly more likely to promote paid products or services, with 32.8% doing so compared to a combined 32.7% across the other three platforms.

Across the entire dataset, only 2.2% of content creators held financial qualifications, and just 11.7% included formal disclaimers in their content or profiles.

Misleading content also drew higher engagement than accurate advice; misleading videos averaged 555,547 views compared to 326,170 views for non-misleading videos. Content focused on trading tips and technical analysis carried the highest overall risk, with 40.6% of those videos categorized as misleading. Additionally, 24.6% of financial literacy education posts were misleading.

ACA’s Take

The rise of uncredentialed financial advice on social media creates significant friction for receivable management professionals attempting to communicate with consumers about valid debts. When consumers rely on inaccurate online guidance regarding credit scores, debt obligations, or legal rights, agencies face longer resolution cycles and higher rates of misinformed disputes.

One way ACA International members are stepping up to help is by sharing the Know My Debt website, which provides reliable consumer education on:

  • Laws and regulations protecting consumers.
  • How to work with debt collectors.
  • Credit reporting and credit scores.
  • Identity theft and consumer concerns.

ACA is also focused on this trend through its advocacy with the Federal Trade Commission, other regulators, and members of Congress.

The prevalence of financial services influencers, or “finfluencers,” online has caused an increase in false identity theft reports. They will encourage consumers to file these reports as a tactic to erase legitimate debt, often using templates that generate inaccurate or incomplete filings.

The online templates encourage consumers to file identity theft forms without a proper understanding of the claim, which may explain the growth in incomplete or inaccurate submissions, ACA has noted to the FTC.

ACA submitted fraud mitigation recommendations to the FTC and has met with the regulator to address these concerns and ensure identity theft claim resources are available to real victims.

ACA urges the FTC to implement stricter verification for disputes to ensure they originate from legitimate consumers with verified identity theft concerns.

Related Content from ACA:

Consumers Are Paying Attention to Credit — But Getting Key Details Wrong

States Race to Close Financial Knowledge Gap While AI Tools Transform Money Advice

 

Remember to subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.

If you have executive leadership updates or other member news to share with ACA, contact our communications department at comm@acainternational.org. View our publications page for more information and our news submission guidelines here.

One moment please...

Share Profile

This site utilizes cookies as included in our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.