A new Commonwealth Fund report finds that premium contributions and deductibles for employer-sponsored insurance now exceed 10% of median household income across nearly half of the country.
02/20/2026 1:00 P.M.
Health care costs for American workers are outstripping wage growth, according to a Feb. 11 report from the Commonwealth Fund. The analysis, “Is Employer Coverage Affordable? How States Stack Up,” reveals that in 19 states, the combined cost of health insurance premiums and deductibles consumes at least 10% of the median household income. This financial strain is most pronounced in Southern states, where lower median incomes collide with rising insurance costs.
The study highlights a geographic divide in the financial burden placed on employees. In Louisiana, for instance, premium contributions and deductibles for family coverage accounted for 15.6% of the median household income. Conversely, workers in Washington, D.C., spent just 5.7% of their income on the same expenses. These disparities are often driven by regional labor market conditions and state-level variations in median income.
While the Commonwealth Fund identifies rising costs as a barrier, research suggests that the difficulty in settling balances is not exclusively a matter of affordability. According to medical bill data from PYMNTS, 44% of consumers encounter significant friction when attempting to pay medical bills. This “last mile” of payment is frequently where the revenue cycle breaks down, often due to administrative hurdles rather than a total lack of funds.
Patients often report that confusing digital interfaces, a lack of preferred payment methods, and difficulty accessing clear billing information lead them to abandon the payment process.
Younger generations — particularly Millennials and Gen Z — expect a seamless, retail-like checkout experience. When portals require multi-step authentication or fail to provide a clear account balance, the likelihood of payment decreases. This administrative friction creates a ripple effect in which unpaid bills are transferred to third-party agencies, not because the patient is unwilling to pay, but because the initial process was too complex to navigate.
The market structure itself is also under scrutiny. At Jan. 22 hearings before the House Energy and Commerce and Ways and Means Committees, lawmakers questioned CEOs at the nation’s five largest health insurers about vertical integration. As reported by ACA International, there is bipartisan concern that single corporations’ ownership of insurers, pharmacy benefit managers, pharmacies and physician groups may be driving up costs and limiting patients’ access to care.
The CEOs of these firms have committed to providing detailed data on subsidiary spending by late February 2026.
The “underinsurance” phenomenon described by the Commonwealth Fund is also worsening. The report defines an individual as underinsured if their deductible equals 5% or more of their household income. In 2024, deductibles reached this level in nearly half of all states.
High deductibles often act as a barrier to care, forcing patients to choose between medical treatment and other essential expenses.
“Premiums and deductibles for many American workers can drain household budgets and increase the risk that people will delay care or take on medical debt,” said Sara Collins, PhD, a senior scholar at the Commonwealth Fund, in a statement accompanying the report.
Looking ahead, the report projects that costs will continue to climb. Factors driving this trend include general inflation, labor shortages within the health care sector, and the rising popularity of high-cost specialty medications. Additionally, the expiration of enhanced Affordable Care Act marketplace tax credits at the end of 2025 has created ripples across the broader insurance market, leading some insurers to raise premiums to hedge against a shifting risk pool.
ACA’s Take
The intersection of the Commonwealth Fund’s data and recent industry reports underscores that medical debt is a product of both high costs and a fragmented payment experience. As ACA previously reported, the “wall” consumers hit is frequently digital or administrative. Reducing this friction requires embracing a mindset focused on the user experience.
Related Content from ACA:
- ACA Daily report: Congress Tackles Health Care Affordability in Bipartisan Talks with Payer CEOs
- ACA Daily report: Medical Debt Friction: Why 44% of Patients Struggle to Complete Payments
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.
A new Commonwealth Fund report finds that premium contributions and deductibles for employer-sponsored insurance now exceed 10% of median household income across nearly half of the country.





