The department’s proposal includes requiring human transfer options tied to automated customer service tools, recordkeeping, and a penalty structure — all subject to a Dec. 18 public hearing.
10/21/2026 12:05 p.m.
Editor’s note: The DCWP has updated the public hearing and comment deadline from Nov. 19 to Dec. 18. The article has been updated to reflect this.
The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) is proposing rules to prohibit certain “deceptive and unconscionable trade practices” tied to widespread and accelerated use of automated customer service systems.
Automated customer service system is defined in the proposed rule as: “any technology used to provide consumers with customer service where all or substantially all the communication to the consumer is made by such technology rather than by a natural person.”
The department says it is focused on automated systems causing consumer harm by wasting time, delaying dispute resolution, and leading to financial losses such as unresolved billing errors, unauthorized charges, and lost account access.
Key components of the proposal include:
- Businesses must clearly inform consumers at the beginning of an interaction that they are communicating with an automated system (such as an AI chatbot) rather than a human.
- Companies must provide an easy, accessible option consisting of a single step (such as a button, voice command, or menu selection) that transfers the consumer to — or queues them for — a human representative. If human agents are not available 24/7, the system must clearly disclose alternative routes to reach a person (e.g., call-back requests, emails, or designated service hours).
- Advertising customer service while deploying automated systems that repeatedly provide irrelevant, erroneous, or dead-end responses constitutes a deceptive and unconscionable trade practice.
The DCWP also makes clear that businesses cannot avoid liability by claiming software errors or technology vendors “caused or assisted in violative acts or omissions.”
Recordkeeping requirements in the proposed rule include creating and retaining records demonstrating compliance for at least three years.
For example, businesses must maintain records related to their use of automated customer service systems for covered interactions, including vendor agreements, system development records, and installation documentation.
The DCWP also proposes a penalty schedule ranging from $525 to $3,500 for first, second, and third defaults and violations, if the rule is finalized.
There will be a public hearing on the proposed rule at 11 a.m. ET on Dec. 18, available for participation via phone or video conference.
Public comments on the proposed rule may be submitted through the rule’s webpage at https://rules.cityofnewyork.us/rule/automated-customer-service-systems/ or by email to rulecomments@dcwp.nyc.gov.
Comments close by Dec. 18, 2026.
The proposed rule underscores a growing regulatory focus on technology that may hinder customer service and legal rights.
While aimed at broad commercial practices, receivables management companies that use automated assistants for account inquiries, fraud alerts, and basic navigation should pay close attention to the DCWP proposal.
Related Content from ACA:
FTC Signals Focus on Corporate Oversight of AI
Bank Regulators Increase Scrutiny of AI Use During Exams
How Industries are Balancing AI Priorities
Fall Forum Breakouts: Turn Today’s Biggest Challenges Into Action
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.
The department’s proposal includes requiring human transfer options tied to automated customer service tools, recordkeeping, and a penalty structure — all subject to a Dec. 18 public hearing.





