0
Skip to content

NY Appellate Court Disbars Attorney Brian Ponder

judge with gavelThe court has stripped a frequent filer of his law license following a pattern of misconduct and a previous disbarment in federal court.

03/09/2026 4:00 P.M.

The Supreme Court of the State of New York, Appellate Division, First Judicial Department, recently issued an order disbarring attorney Brian Lamar Ponder. The March 5 decision follows a motion for reciprocal discipline filed by the Attorney Grievance Committee (AGC), rooted in Ponder’s 2019 disbarment from the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Oklahoma (WDOK).

The court’s opinion describes a history of professional misconduct for eight separate matters in the Oklahoma federal district. According to the court filing, Ponder engaged in a “pattern of misconduct” that included pursuing frivolous claims, missing deadlines and hearings, and failing to engage in good faith discovery.

In one specific instance highlighted by the AGC, Ponder filed a motion to dismiss a defendant on behalf of a plaintiff, which the court granted — but only while directing the plaintiff to pay the defendant’s attorney fees as a sanction. The WDOK court at the time characterized the claims as “spurious” and suggested they were part of an attempt to use the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act as a “shake-down scheme” rather than a legitimate legal remedy.

The New York court noted that Ponder failed to notify state authorities of his 2019 Oklahoma disbarment, a violation of New York court rules. While Ponder did not contest the imposition of reciprocal discipline in the New York proceedings, he requested a lighter sanction, such as public censure or a three-month suspension. The court rejected that request.

The underlying Oklahoma investigation also detailed a 2018 deposition where Ponder’s client used profanity and “vile” insults toward opposing counsel. The court found that Ponder sat by and “pretended not to hear” the remarks, failing to intervene as any reasonable attorney would have done.

“We find that disbarment is the appropriate sanction in this matter as it is commensurate with the discipline imposed by the WDOK,” the court stated in its opinion.

Impact on Pending Litigation

Ponder has been a frequent filer of lawsuits against members of the accounts receivable management industry. Records indicate several active cases in New York involving Ponder as counsel of record.

Current pending matters include Mahdi v. Midland Credit Management, Inc. in the Southern District of New York and Washington III v. LVNV Funding LLC in the New York Supreme Court. Many of these cases involve allegations of FDCPA violations, improper debt validation, or wrongful credit reporting.

The disbarment, effective immediately, prohibits Ponder from practicing law in any form or holding himself out as an attorney in New York. This development leaves several consumer-plaintiffs in a position where they must find new representation, proceed pro se, or risk dismissal of their claims.

ACA’s Take

This disciplinary action serves as a reminder of the importance of maintaining rigorous defense strategies when facing high-volume filers who may be operating outside the bounds of professional conduct.

The court’s findings echo frustrations often voiced by ARM industry professionals regarding meritless litigation.

“As attorneys, we find it hard to take pleasure in another’s loss of his license, but we will note that this punishment is well-deserved and too slow in coming,” Manny Newburger, shareholder at Barron & Newburger, P.C., said in his write-up of the case.

Members with active cases involving this respondent should consult with their defense counsel to monitor the status of those matters, as the plaintiffs will likely be required to secure new counsel.

Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.

If you have executive leadership updates or other member news to share with ACA, contact our communications department at comm@acainternational.org. View our publications page for more information and our news submission guidelines here.

One moment please...

Share Profile

This site utilizes cookies as included in our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.