0
Skip to content

NJ Court Strikes Down Limits on Attorney Debt Adjustment Services

The court said that the state can’t restrict attorneys’ debt adjustment practices.

05/14/2025 2:40 P.M.

2 minute read

Last week a New Jersey appellate court invalidated restrictions on attorneys who provide debt adjustment services to clients. The ruling in Anchor Law Firm, PLLC v. State of New Jersey restores the full attorney exemption that existed before 1986, allowing all attorneys to engage in debt adjustment activities without fear of penalties under the Debt Adjustment and Credit Counseling Act (DACCA).

DACCA prohibits debt adjusters from operating for-profit in New Jersey, with violations subject to civil penalties and potential fourth-degree criminal charges.

The case centered on DACCA’s “limited attorney exemption,” which since 1986 has exempted only attorneys “not principally engaged as a debt adjuster” from the act’s prohibitions and penalties. Anchor Law Firm and attorney Andrew Carroll challenged this provision after becoming the subject of an Office of Attorney Ethics investigation.

Carroll represents consumers in bankruptcy and collection cases.

The appellate court invalidated DACCA’s limited attorney exemption on two grounds:

  • It violates separation of powers principles by encroaching on the U.S. Supreme Court’s exclusive authority to regulate attorneys.
  • The term “principally engaged” is undefined and lacks clear criteria for enforcement.

“Simply put, the legislature properly adhered to the constitutional boundary in passing the 1961 law but crossed over the line in the 1986 enactment,” the court stated in the ruling.

The ruling effectively restores the full attorney exemption that existed before 1986, allowing attorneys to engage in debt adjustment activities without fear of DACCA penalties. This includes negotiating with creditors, representing clients in bankruptcy proceedings, and advising on debt consolidation or settlement.

Fundamentally, the decision invalidates the “principally engaged” limitation set forth in the attorney exemption. The rest of DACCA, however, remains intact and applies to non-attorney debt adjusters.

The removal of the “principally engaged” limitation will allow attorneys to perform an array of legal work—like negotiating with creditors, representing clients in bankruptcy proceedings, defending debtors in collection actions, and advising on debt consolidation or settlement—without having to obtain a debt-adjustment license.

The court’s decision is effective immediately.

ACA’s Take

This ruling mirrors a similar ruling issued by the Connecticut Supreme Court in April 2025, which asserted the judiciary’s independence to regulate legal practice under the state constitution. Note that not all state constitutions will have the same separation of powers language.

Although both the New Jersey and Connecticut decisions related to the practice of law insofar as it involves “debt adjustment” or “debt negotiation,” and therefore neither directly address ARM-industry attorneys, the rationale and legal logic underlying both decisions can be invoked to protect, at least to some degree, the ARM-relevant practice of law from regulation by state legislatures and regulators.

Read the full case here.

If you have executive leadership updates or other member news to share with ACA, contact our communications department at comm@acainternational.org. View our publications page for more information and our news submission guidelines here.

One moment please...

Share Profile

This site utilizes cookies as included in our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.