The court rejected the consumer’s six-year-late challenge to default judgment, reinforcing the finality principle.
11/06/2025 12:00 P.M.
3 minute read
The New Jersey Appellate Division delivered a significant win for debt collection practices on Nov. 5, 2025, affirming that consumers cannot wait years to challenge judgments they’ve already satisfied.
The decision in Unifund CCR LLC v. Garabedian reinforces critical principles of judicial finality while clarifying the limits of consumer challenges under state licensing laws — a victory that impacts other ACA International members facing similar claims across New Jersey.
Unifund CCR LLC, an ACA member company, successfully defended a default judgment against Christine Garabedian for $7,282.36 in credit card debt originally owed to First National Bank of Omaha. The debt passed through several assignments before Unifund acquired it and filed a collection complaint in July 2018. When Garabedian failed to respond, the court entered a default judgment in February 2019. She satisfied the judgment in full by April 2023.
The case took an unexpected turn in June 2024 when Garabedian, more than six years after the judgment and 14 months after paying it, moved to vacate the judgment. She argued the debt was void because intermediate debt buyers Pilot Receivables Management and Distressed Asset Portfolio III lacked required licenses under New Jersey’s Consumer Finance Licensing Act (NJCFLA)— a theory increasingly deployed against debt collectors in the Garden State.
The trial court denied the motion, finding Garabedian failed to act within a reasonable timeframe and demonstrated no excusable neglect. The court emphasized that even if the judgment were void from inception, the extraordinary delay defeated “the strong interest of finality of judgments and judicial efficiency.”
On appeal, the Appellate Division affirmed multiple arguments that dismantle a troubling litigation strategy. Most significantly, the court held that the NJCFLA provides no private right of action for consumers.
Citing its recent precedent in Francavilla v. Absolute Resolutions VI, the panel explained that only the Commissioner of Banking and Insurance can enforce licensing requirements through administrative actions, penalties, or criminal prosecution. Rule 4:50-1(d) or (f) does not entitle consumers to bring private actions based on licensing violations, meaning lack of licensure cannot be a basis to void or vacate judgments.
“This is a fatal flaw in plaintiffs’ entire series of litigation under the act,” said Rick Perr, co-managing partner for Kaufman Dolowich, who successfully argued the case.
As a matter of law, none of the underlying debts can be voided before the commissioner makes such a determination.
“And if the debts are not void, then none of the collection activity violates the FDCPA,” Perr said.
This holding distinguishes the NJCFLA from the federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, which explicitly authorizes private lawsuits. The court rejected Garabedian’s reliance on LVNV Funding v. Deangelo, where a judgment was vacated based on FDCPA violations, noting the critical difference in statutory structure.
Even if Garabedian could have asserted such a claim, the court found her six-year delay fundamentally unreasonable. She knew about the judgment when Unifund sought wage garnishment in 2019 but waited until after satisfying it to challenge its validity.
ACA’s Take
The decision provides crucial clarity for ACA member companies operating in New Jersey’s complex regulatory environment, particularly those fighting similar claims that attempting to collect on unlicensed debt creates private rights of action.
It confirms that passive debt buyers in assignment chains do not necessarily trigger licensing requirements that would void subsequent collection actions by licensed entities. More broadly, it reinforces that courts will not permit stale challenges to judgments, particularly after consumers have received notice and satisfied their obligations.
The court rejected the consumer’s six-year-late challenge to default judgment, reinforcing the finality principle.





