0
Skip to content

Market Snapshot: Q4 2024 Earnings Call Highlights

computer with bills and moneyARM industry outlook culled from recent earnings calls of three publicly traded debt collection companies: Encore, Navient and PRA Group.

02/27/2025 2:45 P.M.

10 minute read

Three of the largest publicly traded debt collection companies—Encore Capital Group, Navient and PRA Group—recently held their Q4 2024 earnings calls. As public companies with required market disclosures, their earnings calls offer an opportunity to glean macro-insights on the collections world and the economy in general.

Here are some highlights from the calls that speak to larger accounts receivable management industry trends.

Economic Overview
“The U.S. Federal Reserve has been reporting that revolving credit in the U.S. has been rising since early 2021. At the same time, since bottoming out in late 2021, the credit card charge-off rate in the U.S. has also been rising and is now at its highest level in more than 10 years. The combination of higher lending and growth in the charge-off rate is driving record portfolio supply in the U.S.

Similarly, U.S. consumer credit card delinquencies, which are a leading indicator of future charge-offs, also remain at multi-year highs. With both lending and the charge-off rate at elevated levels, purchasing conditions in the U.S. market remain highly favorable. We are observing continued strong U.S. market supply and attractive pricing as well. Delinquency data at year-end supports our expectation that 2025 will be another year of very strong portfolio sales by U.S. banks and credit card issuers.

With portfolio supply in the U.S. surging to its highest level ever in 2024, we purchased significantly more volume than we ever have in the U.S.”
– Ashish Masih, president & CEO, Encore Capital Group

 

Offshore Strategy
“[We are focused on] the development and expansion of our offshore teams in two low-cost locations in Asia. After having virtually no offshore presence in the U.S. prior, we leveraged third-party vendors to roll out our first offshore call center at the end of 2023 and accelerated this expansion throughout 2024, launching a second call center and ramping up hiring in both locations.

In the second half of 2024, we launched a work-from-home initiative for our U.S. collectors. Along with providing greater flexibility for eligible collectors, this initiative, coupled with the performance of our offshore collectors, has enabled us to begin consolidating our U.S. call center footprint. And as previously noted, we are on track to reduce it from six to three operating sites by mid-2025.

The mix of onshore versus offshore collectors in the second half of 2025 will reflect a variety of factors, including U.S. investment levels, collector attrition trends, and overall performance of the respective teams. As of year-end, our offshore collectors account for more than 30% of our overall collector base, supporting our U.S. business, and we anticipate this mix to approach 50% in the second half of 2025.

In summary, our offshoring strategy is helping us create a more variable cost structure, enhance our calling strategies, and better navigate the ebbs and flows of the credit cycle.”
– Vikram Atal, president & CEO, PRA Group

 

“Last time, we mentioned that based on the number of collectors we had offshore and the annualized savings that we attributed to them of about $10 million, the basic batch was about $30,000 per collector savings. So, dollar-wise, expense-wise, it’s a meaningful save if we can move up there. From a productivity standpoint, [our offshore teams] are absolutely on track relative to expectations. Obviously, we sort of benchmark them against an equivalent tenured collector in the U.S., because obviously, collectors’ performance generally improves and correlates to the level of tenure they have here. So, if you look at collectors that have got a tenure of less than one year, because that’s the average tenure of our folks overseas, our collectors are performing on par.

We are actually experiencing dampened attrition in our offshore collectors relative to the attrition rates that we experienced in our onshore collectors, so that’s encouraging as well.”
– Vikram Atal, president & CEO, PRA Group

 

Legal Collections
“Legal collection costs were up $11 million year over year, driven primarily by investments in our U.S. legal collections channel to drive future growth. While investments in the legal collections channel creates a near-term drag on earnings and cash efficiency due to the lag between when we invest in the upfront court costs and when we start collecting cash, we are confident that these investments will drive strong cash collections over the next several years.
In fact, we are already starting to see a pay-off from prior investments, as Vik noted earlier. As a reminder, we do not begin our collections activity with the legal collections channel, but consider using it if and when our customers do not engage with us voluntarily.”
– Rakesh Sehgal, chief financial officer and executive vice president, PRA Group

 

“We’re all watching what’s happening in D.C. and then beyond. But given the unpredictability of the political and the general environment, it’s sort of a little premature for us to go too far ahead on our skis on this. It’s not just the CFPB. There is a plethora of regulations covering our industry that’s codified in law and in various sort of orders that have been passed over time. Just as an example, I think we mentioned before, the thousands of jurisdictions that you’ve got to navigate when you’re managing a legal process. And so just for competitors coming in here, setting up a capability that will allow them to do that is a multi-year effort and not for the faint of heart.”
– Vikram Atal, president & CEO, PRA Group

 

“Within the U.S., the legal collections channel is less impacted by near-term consumer pressure, given the longer time period over which we collect cash. Our other U.S. core collection channels, which are most susceptible to near-term U.S. consumer pressure, accounted for less than 25% of our global cash collections, demonstrating that our collections aren’t entirely dependent on near-term U.S. macroeconomic factors.

In addition, unlike credit issuers who generally need to address and resolve consumer delinquencies over a relatively short period of time, our business model has a much longer time horizon, allowing us to work with customers and tailor payment plans according to their evolving financial situations. This gives us the ability to work closely with our customers, especially during times when they are experiencing financial difficulties, and enables us to continue generating cash over the long term.”
– Rakesh Sehgal, chief financial officer and executive vice president, PRA Group

 

“On legal collections for the U.S., let me just highlight that it is a kind of tool, as you mentioned, that we don’t use as a first go. We are collecting better and better in a call center and digital channel, first of all. So let me point out that the share of call center and digital is at a record high. So legal is at a record low. It’s like at 36% for the year now. And we had gone to that level in the COVID times when a lot of consumer payments were coming in. So, we’re feeling very good about how effectively call center and digital is collecting. MCM is growing, buying a lot of volume. So, the legal expense, the dollar number has risen, and I think we’re getting to be in the right ballpark and maybe a little bit more here and there, but it has to be the right ZIP code. And as we continue to deploy omni-channel and call center strategies, I expect more and more to come through that way.”
– Ashish Masih, president & CEO, Encore Capital Group

 

Tax Season
Audience question: “There was a lot of color on you monitoring the health of the U.S. consumer, and things seem relatively benign right now. But are you seeing any emerging signs? There’s some—I wouldn’t call it odd data, but preliminary data from the IRS. There’s a lot more refunds, but a lot less returns, but it’s only a couple of weeks of data. But any trends you’re seeing either in Q4 of this year at the beginning of tax season that may change your color from benign to better than benign or worse than benign?”

“I agree. Look, folks start submitting their taxes at the end of January. It takes about three weeks. So, it’s just early days. We are seeing the same data that you are seeing in terms of trends over the last three years. I think the key is also the earned income tax credit. We really focus on that because a number of our customers benefit from that. And as you know, the date just came out that that would be released early March, March 3 to be exact. So, we’ll be monitoring that as well. And then I think we’ll have a better idea as to how the tax season would flow into our business.”
– Rakesh Sehgal, chief financial officer and executive vice president, PRA Group

 

Student Loans
“Consumer lending is well positioned to continue to grow origination volume and demonstrate operating leverage in 2025. We plan to increase loan origination volume by 30% this year. A large portion of that growth is expected in the second half of the year based on the current interest rate environment and the seasonal pattern of in-school originations. There are, as you all know, a number of comprehensive proposals the new administration may consider in determining federal education loan policies and practices. These proposals contain elements that would produce expanded opportunities for private lending. Among these are a reduction or elimination of loan forgiveness programs and the elimination of the Grad PLUS loan program.

The Grad PLUS loans include a program for graduate students. Origination levels in this program are roughly the current size of private student lending. A majority of our in-school lending is to graduate students. It’s a market we understand well and are offering products and a customer experience tailored to the needs of this segment. It’s too soon to tell what elements may be implemented or when they’ll be implemented. But we possess the capacity, flexibility, products, and customer experience and are excited about this potential sizable opportunity.

With that said, our 2025 plans do not yet assume any expanded opportunities for our products as a result of policy changes.”
– David Yowan, CEO, Navient

 

“As you know, there’s a number of comprehensive proposals, some focused more on federal education lending policy, some focused on broader parts of the government structure, but they include potential changes in federal education loan policy. And within those proposals, there’s a large number of elements. I think there’s two things in all those proposals that are foreseeable and the impact and potential opportunity for us are foreseeable as well.

The first is lower levels of loan forgiveness and perhaps changes in IDR programs. Those have an impact on our federal, our FFELP portfolio, for example, which was impacted last year by a high level of consolidation activity, which in turn was driven by a high level of loan forgiveness programs that were offered in the federal loan program. So, to the extent those are more predictable and even lower than they have been in the past, that extends the life of our existing debt portfolio, which obviously we think is a good thing.”
– David Yowan, CEO, Navient

 

“Before I go into the segments, I’d like to pause and acknowledge the devastating wildfires that struck Southern California [in January]. I encourage all borrowers who have been impacted by this disaster and other natural disasters in recent quarters to take advantage of the various relief programs that we and the Department of Education offer to help you during these challenging times.

Late-stage delinquencies increased from the prior quarter to 2.7%, while forbearance rates decreased from the prior quarter to 2.7%. The decrease in forbearance is primarily a result of the disaster relief that was granted to the followers impacted by federally declared natural disasters in the third quarter that returned to repayment in the fourth quarter.”
– Joe Fisher, CFO, Navient

Editor’s Note: All quotes taken from call transcripts provided by Yahoo! Finance and Seeking Alpha and were lightly edited for clarity.

Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA profile when logged in to acainternational.org to receive updates on the ACA Huddle.

 

If you have executive leadership updates or other member news to share with ACA, contact our communications department at comm@acainternational.org. View our publications page for more information and our news submission guidelines here.

One moment please...

Share Profile

This site utilizes cookies as included in our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.