The committee has requested a review of the bureau’s use of statutory authority under former Director Rohit Chopra.
06/30/2025 11:35 a.m.
6 minute read
The House Financial Services Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations recently convened to review Consumer Financial Protection Bureau oversight for the first time since former director Rohit Chopra’s departure and the transition to acting leadership.
“The CFPB was created to be a nonpartisan watchdog—an agency tasked with protecting American consumers from deceptive, unfair, and abusive financial practices,” said U.S. Rep. Dan Meuser, R-N.Y., who chairs the subcommittee, in his opening remarks for the hearing titled “From Watchdog to Attack Dog: Examining the CFPB’s Chopra-era Assault on Disfavored Industries.”
Meuser continued, “But under Director Chopra, that mission was abandoned. The CFPB ceased to be a pro-consumer agency and instead became a[n] ideological weapon—used not to protect the public, but to pressure businesses into aligning with the CFPB’s goals through aggressive rules, enforcement, and supervision.”
Testifying before the committee were former CFPB employees, experienced congressional witnesses, and individuals who had directly faced the bureau’s investigative demands and regulatory examinations.
The discussion explored the agency’s expansive powers to conduct investigations, its practice of establishing rules through enforcement actions rather than formal rulemaking, and how these regulatory approaches affected both consumers and the business community.
“The question here is not whether this committee is interested in consumer protection. It’s dedicated to consumer protection. The facts here are how to do it, do it in the right way [and] the appropriate way based on business strategy, business size, business entity and in conjunction with … the federal statute,” said U.S. Rep. French Hill, chair of the House Financial Services Committee. “[It’s about] being true to that statute and not inventing law out of whole cloth or operating by regulation by enforcement. That is not the way our state and federal regulatory system has operated over the decades.”
Civil Investigative Demands
Members of the subcommittee reviewed the impact of the bureau’s Civil Investigative Demands [CID] on companies, including Pacific Rim Alliance Corporation.
The CFPB’s investigation of the company is ongoing and started almost three years ago.
“The bureau’s endless investigation of Pacific Rim is a prime example of the weaponization of an agency that was designed to provide protection to consumers and recourse for those who have been harmed,” said CEO Jennifer Bassett. “The CFPB has never identified any consumer harm or violation of law by Pacific Rim. Further, the process provided to a company like ours for relief is woefully inadequate. Once served with a CID, a company has no way out other than to capitulate to the bureau’s demands, no matter how unreasonable, costly, and burdensome they are.”
Meuser said use of CIDs is “one of the most troubling examples of … overreach” by the bureau.
“For many businesses, especially small ones, the process of responding to a CID is a challenging task—often leading to layoffs, loss of customers, and in some cases, closures,” he said.
U.S. Rep. Andy Barr, R-Ky., and Vicente Gonzalez, D-Texas, introduced the Civil Investigative Demand Reform Act last year to ensure industry participants are given due process.
Bassett said she hoped the subcommittee continues to support this bipartisan legislation.
Competitive Enterprise Institute attorney Devin Watkins detailed how the bureau’s Civil Investigative Demands and enforcement strategies affect regulated entities.
“Regulatory enforcement abuse, such as occurred at the CFPB, is just another form of prosecutorial abuse. A normal prosecutor waits for a potential victim, examines the evidence to see if a well-known violation of the law occurred, and then brings enforcement to protect that specific victim,” Watkins said. “The problem occurs when the prosecutors follow the old Soviet saying, ‘Show me the man, and I’ll show you the crime.’ … The rule of law is not a partisan issue. It is the foundation of our republic. Without it, no one is safe from arbitrary power. If we are to remain a free people, governed by laws and not by bureaucrats, then Congress must ensure that government agencies are themselves bound by the law.”
The Future of the Bureau
Under Acting Director Russell Vought’s leadership, the bureau has prioritized evaluating existing regulations, reviewing policy guidance, and assessing personnel matters.
Hill said the subcommittee’s discussion came at a good time to analyze the bureau’s work.
“We have a system in place, let’s use it. If you want to come advocate through the Federal Register and promulgate a rule or promulgate enforcement of a rule, do it,” Hill said. “This back door enforcement work … I just can’t condone it.”
Former CFPB enforcement attorney and current Cooley LLP partner James Kim endorsed the committee’s efforts and advocated for increased dialogue between the bureau and industry stakeholders.
“The CFPB has a critical mission to protect American consumers,” and I believe in that mission,” Kim said. “Compared to other federal agencies, the CFPB is still a startup. And like other startups … it needs reminders to stay faithful to its mission and its core principles, and it needs adjustments to better execute its mission.”
Kim added, “Most importantly, the bureau should focus on engaging with and gathering information from stakeholders at the ground level. All CFPB functions from supervision to regulation to enforcement should be driven by data collected from a wide range of sources rather than siloed top-down decisions from agency leadership. The bureau should focus on engaging with and gathering information from stakeholders and actions should be driven by data.”
During the session, members of Congress explored strategies to modernize the CFPB while ensuring its regulatory procedures remain equitable and balanced.
“I am excited that we are taking a fresh look at the CFPB,” said U.S. Rep. Mike Haridopolos, R-Fla. “I don’t want to litigate fights in the past either. I want to move this country forward [and] want to make sure we are moving forward in administrating the Administrative Procedure Act.”
Haridopolos added, “When a company comes into play, we want them to have a fair umpire instead of someone picking winners or losers, which clearly some of the folks before were doing. This agency was playing politics. … The [CFPB] would pick on folks who they necessarily didn’t like, and they would run them into the ground, run up expenses, and make it very hard for them to compete in an increasingly competitive world. I applaud this oversight meeting, and I think it is going to be very helpful as we move forward.”
The committee seeks to propose changes that would make the CFPB’s regulatory procedures more visible to the public while establishing a more equitable framework for implementing and enforcing rules.
Before the hearing, Meuser sent a letter (PDF) to the CFPB’s inspector general requesting an investigation into Chopra’s “unlawful expansion of the CFPB’s statutory authority,” according to a news release.
The letter requests the inspector general conduct a comprehensive investigation into the CFPB’s adherence to proper processes and procedures, including Chopra’s increased coordination with state attorneys general, exceeding the statutory authority granted under the Consumer Financial Protection Act and the time and costs associated with enforcement actions from Chopra compared to previous directors.
Access a recording of the subcommittee’s discussion here.
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.
The committee has requested a review of the bureau’s use of statutory authority under former Director Rohit Chopra.





