Buy Now, Pay Later services have made luxury instantly accessible to young consumers. But mounting debt and new credit score rules signal turbulent times ahead, The New York Times reports.
10/13/2025 9:00 A.M.
3 minute read
The Buy Now, Pay Later industry has created a seismic shift in consumer credit trends.
With an estimated half of Americans having used BNPL services at least once — and half of those users being under age 33 — a new generation of debtors is emerging with distinctly different financial behaviors and challenges, an Oct. 7 report from The New York Times found.
When consumers use a BNPL service, they make a smaller payment upfront and have the ability to postpone the balance for weeks, months, or even years.
“Nearly two-thirds of Coachella concertgoers this year used it to afford their tickets,” according to The New York Times. “You can Afterpay a vacation: flights, cruises, Airbnbs, the whole shebang. You can Klarna a burrito.”
While advertised as “interest free,” longer-term BNPL plans can carry interest rates as high as 36 percent, The New York Times reported, with late fees accumulating when automatic payments fail to clear linked accounts.
Psychological Insights
Research from University of Leeds professor Dionysius Ang reveals the psychological trap embedded in BNPL’s design. Her study of 275,000 consumers found that shoppers “were 9% more likely to make purchases” when choosing BNPL options, and those who opted in “ended up spending more money,” with purchases totaling 10% more, on average. The platforms also drive repeat business, with consumers “coming back more frequently to make further purchases.”
According to the Federal Reserve’s 2024 analysis, BNPL users have lower overall financial well-being than their peers, with many indicating it was “the only way they could afford” their purchases. Britain’s Financial Conduct Authority similarly found that BNPL users often had higher levels of unsecured debt.
The Regulatory Landscape
BNPL companies have long operated in a regulatory gray area, The New York Times reported. Because most BNPL terms run four to six weeks, they fall outside the Truth in Lending Act, which only requires clear disclosure of interest rates and fees for loans longer than four months.
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau issued an interpretive rule on BNPL in 2024 that classified the lenders as credit card providers, ACA International reported. But earlier this year, the CFPB announced it was changing course on enforcement actions related to BNPL. In May, the bureau withdrew several guidance documents, including the BNPL interpretive rule.
The game-changer arrives this fall when FICO begins incorporating BNPL loan histories into credit scores — a development that may surprise young consumers who’ve accumulated multiple payment plans without traditional credit consequences.
Additionally, ACA reported on FICO’s announcement that the new additions of FICO® Score 10 BNPL and FICO® Score 10 T BNPL will provide lenders with greater visibility into consumers’ repayment behaviors. This enables a more comprehensive view of their credit readiness, ultimately improving the lending experience.
With traditional credit card companies launching BNPL-style features and BNPL providers like Klarna issuing physical cards, the lines between credit products are blurring.
ACA’s Take
According to a TransUnion survey, 21% of debt collection companies said they worked BNPL accounts over the last 12 months.
The financial services sector should prepare for a wave of younger, financially inexperienced debtors who may not fully understand their BNPL obligations — and to navigate an evolving regulatory framework that’s still finding its footing.
Trends in this area include:
- Younger, less experienced debtors: With half of BNPL users under 33, many may be navigating their first debt collection experience.
- Multiple small debts: Unlike traditional credit cards, consumers often have numerous BNPL accounts across different platforms, creating confusion about total obligations.
- Credit score impacts: When FICO begins reporting BNPL histories this fall, expect increased consumer confusion and disputes.
Buy Now, Pay Later services have made luxury instantly accessible to young consumers. But mounting debt and new credit score rules signal turbulent times ahead, The New York Times reports.





