Federal Reserve data shows 16% of consumers used BNPL in 2025, leaving traditional lenders with an incomplete financial picture. States like New York and Illinois are stepping in with new oversight frameworks as lenders and debt collection agencies adapt to shifting consumer risk profiles.
10/05/2026 12:30 P.M.
Rising adoption of Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) loans is creating a significant underwriting blind spot for traditional financial institutions, according to a recent American Banker report analyzing Federal Reserve data.
About 16% of consumers used BNPL products in 2025. Usage was driven largely by lower-income households, younger consumers, and borrowers with thin credit files, who turned to short-term installment loans for everyday expenses like groceries, according to the report.
Because most BNPL lenders do not furnish payment data to credit reporting agencies, traditional credit bureau files often omit BNPL obligations, causing lenders to understate a borrower’s true monthly debt-to-income (DTI) ratio.
The 16% usage figure comes from the Federal Reserve Board’s Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households Report and the Fed’s Survey of Household Economics and Decisionmaking.
Unreported BNPL commitments mean traditional underwriting may rely on an incomplete financial picture, particularly for credit cards, auto loans, and mortgages, according to American Banker’s analysis.
The Fed data indicates BNPL usage was highest (31%) among adults who could not cover a $100 emergency expense with savings, compared to just 8% among those able to cover $2,000 or more.
“BNPL is still largely invisible debt,” Anna Kooi, a partner at Wipfli, told American Banker. “Most pay-in-four loans don’t appear on a credit report, so a bank underwriting a credit card, auto loan or mortgage may be working from an incomplete picture of what the borrower actually owes each month.”
Industry experts advise financial institutions to incorporate cash-flow underwriting into their risk assessment, using internal transaction and deposit data to identify recurring payments to BNPL providers and adjust DTI calculations accordingly.
“The whole economic system is driving people to use these products, which is ultimately creating more risk in the market,” Daniela Hawkins, a partner at Capco, said in the American Banker article.
In a recent episode of The New York Times’ The Daily, financial reporter Stacy Cowley highlighted how BNPL options have evolved over the past two years. Once used primarily for small online purchases, BNPL providers now offer payment cards and financing for recurring living expenses, including rent.
Consumers interviewed said they have maxed out their credit cards and could not have made purchases for food or car repairs without BNPL loans, according to Cowley’s interview, “Buy Now, Pay Later: A New Wave of Consumer Debt.”
State regulators are actively developing rules for BNPL financing.
Under draft rules from the New York State Department of Financial Services (NYDFS), BNPL providers would be required to evaluate a borrower’s income and debt obligations prior to approving each transaction, ACA previously reported. The regulations also propose new licensing and supervision structures, dispute resolution procedures, credit reporting standards, fee caps, and data privacy mandates for lenders operating in the state.
The American Fintech Council (AFC) and the Financial Technology Association submitted formal comments urging the NYDFS to reconsider key aspects of its draft BNPL framework.
“Requiring mandatory assessments of income and indebtedness for every transaction effectively imposes an ability-to-repay requirement that the enacted statute does not contain,” according to the AFC letter.
The AFC said the proposed requirements could reduce accessible credit to New York residents by more than $500 million annually.
The state-level push in New York reflects a broader regulatory shift nationwide. In June 2026, Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker signed the Buy-Now-Pay-Later Loan Consumer Protection Act into law, which established statewide refund and dispute-resolution standards.
At the federal level, oversight momentum has shifted. Although the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau previously moved to increase scrutiny of BNPL products, the agency has since pulled back on those regulatory efforts.
Meanwhile, members of Congress continue to examine the industry, with several U.S. senators requesting transaction and default data from major lenders including Affirm, Klarna, Afterpay, and PayPal. And earlier this year, a group of U.S. senators sent letters to Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion asking for more information on how they handle BNPL transactions.
As state regulators step in to establish rules for BNPL financing, receivables management professionals face an evolving credit landscape. The potential for reduced credit availability or shifting underwriting mandates in major markets like New York highlights the broader struggle to fit nontraditional installment credit into existing regulatory frameworks.
According to a TransUnion survey, 16% of debt collection companies worked on BNPL accounts over the last year. As these accounts become more common, receivables management agencies should prepare to work with consumers managing several small, concurrent debts rather than a single large balance.
Related Content from ACA:
- Younger Consumers Use Personal Loans for Everyday Living Expenses
- BNPL Users Struggle with On-Time Payments as Usage Expands
Remember to subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.
Federal Reserve data shows 16% of consumers used BNPL in 2025, leaving traditional lenders with an incomplete financial picture. States like New York and Illinois are stepping in with new oversight frameworks as lenders and debt collection agencies adapt to shifting consumer risk profiles.





