A Payments Dive article explores how the industry is falling under the purview of state laws that were not intended for buy now, pay later transactions.
12/01/2025 1:30 P.M.
3 minute read
Buy now, pay later companies have long operated in a regulatory gray area. A new Payments Dive report shares that in the absence of federal laws, states are stepping up to regulate BNPL companies.
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau issued an interpretive rule on BNPL in 2024 that classified the lenders as credit card providers, ACA International reported. But earlier this year, the CFPB announced it was changing course on enforcement actions related to BNPL. In May, the bureau withdrew several guidance documents, including the BNPL interpretive rule.
States Step Up
“Many state AGs have signaled that they are worried about BNPL,” Adam Rust, director of financial services for the Consumer Federation of America, told Payments Dive.
Several states have implemented new laws for BNPL companies, while others lumped them into existing laws.
“Arkansas, for example, does not require any lenders to have a license, according to a rundown of state loan licensing rules related to BNPL by Bloomberg Law. To add to the confusion, some states have laws regulating payday lenders, which may also cover buy now, pay later companies,” Payments Dive reported.
Nearly 75% of states have payday lending laws in place.
Back in 2020, California became the first state to address BNPL companies, classifying BNPL products as loans and requiring a license to operate in the state.
New York’s law imposes licensing and supervision requirements on BNPL lenders, prohibits excessive fees, and caps interest on BNPL products to 16%.
Nevada’s law ended a requirement that BNPL lenders maintain a physical location in the state, but also requires lenders to use state law to govern the loans.
Maryland’s BNPL rules are “complex,” Antonio Salazar, the state’s commissioner of financial regulation, explained to Payments Dive. Under the law, some BNPL companies may be exempt from licensing requirements, while others must hold a consumer lending license to operate in Maryland.
“The new state laws have gone in opposite directions. While New York has taken an aggressive approach, Nevada has moved to smooth the path for buy now, pay later companies,” Payments Dive reported. “Most states have elected to regulate BNPL transactions under existing statutes related to payday lending and banking, but enforcement has been uneven, according to payments executives and industry consultants.”
BNPL Use is Up — So Are Late Payments
Lenders and collectors may face a looming challenge as consumers increasingly use BNPL options, taking out multiple loans and making more late payments.
More than 4 in 10 (41%) users of BNPL loans say they paid late on one of them in the past year, up from 34% just a year ago, according to LendingTree.
The Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond has noted that “while no official data is available for current BNPL delinquencies, the Financial Technology Association — which counts three BNPL lenders among its members — reports a delinquency rate among those companies of less than 2 percent. In comparison, the aggregate delinquency rate of overall consumer debts was 3.5 percent in the third quarter of 2024, including 8.8 percent of credit card balances transitioning to delinquency. The BNPL delinquencies, however, tend to be a lower-bound measure of its credit risks, because BNPL may have spillover effects onto other consumer credit products.”
BNPL Loans Will Soon Affect Credit Scores
Currently, BNPL loans don’t affect consumers’ credit scores, whether payments are made on time or late. However, almost 4 in 10 Americans (38%) are unaware that FICO will soon include BNPL data in its scoring model — which was scheduled to launch fall 2025 — and this shift could potentially lower scores for the 49% who have missed payments.
These new scores will “represent a significant advancement in credit scoring, accounting for the growing importance of BNPL loans in the U.S. credit ecosystem,” ACA International previously reported.
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA profile when logged in to acainternational.org.
A Payments Dive article explores how the industry is falling under the purview of state laws that were not intended for buy now, pay later transactions.





