0
Skip to content

Court Grants Defendant’s Motion to Extend Data Breach Case

cybersecurity regulationThe court granted in part and denied in part Memorial Heart Institute’s motion to dismiss data breach claims. Concerned about your company’s data security? Joining ACA’s Cybersecurity Collective can help you keep up with the latest cyber threats.

10/08/2024 4:00 P.M.

4.5 minute read

In a recent ruling, the U.S. District Court Eastern District of Tennessee at Chattanooga has partially denied and partially granted Memorial Heart Institute’s (MHI) motion to dismiss in a significant data breach case. The case, Cahill v. Memorial Heart Institute, LLC (PDF), stems from a cybersecurity incident on April 17, 2023 that compromised the personal and health information of approximately 411,000 individuals.

Background

Former patients of MHI filed a lawsuit against the Tennessee-based health care provider alleging that it failed to adequately protect their sensitive data including Social Security numbers.

The plaintiffs claimed that MHI’s delayed notification of the breach, which wasn’t communicated to affected patients until late July, exacerbated their concerns about the mishandling of personal information.

The plaintiffs allege that MHI failed to implement adequate cybersecurity measures to protect sensitive data, despite being aware of the increasing risk of cyberattacks against health care providers. They argue that MHI’s systems were inadequate and did not meet industry standards recommended by organizations, such as the Federal Trade Commission. The plaintiffs claim that MHI’s negligence resulted in personal data being compromised, leading to potential identity theft and financial harm.

In response to the breach, MHI offered a year of credit monitoring services, which the plaintiffs argued was insufficient given the circumstances. They asserted that they have incurred expenses related to protective measures, such as credit monitoring and fraud prevention, and they continue to face risks associated with identity theft.

Case Considerations

The consolidated complaint includes various claims against MHI, including:

  • Negligence;
  • Negligence per se;
  • Breach of implied contract;
  • Unjust enrichment;
  • Bailment;
  • Breach of fiduciary duty;
  • Invasion of privacy; and
  • Declaratory and injunctive relief.

Under Tennessee law, to establish negligence per se, plaintiffs must demonstrate: (1) a violation of a statutory or regulatory duty of care; (2) that the statute or regulation was intended to protect the injured party; and (3) proximate cause.

The plaintiffs claimed the defendant violated the FTC Act, HIPAA, the Georgia Fair Business Practices Act, and the Tennessee Consumer Protection Act. The defendant moved to dismiss the negligence per se claim, arguing that none of these statutes established a specific standard of care.

The court granted the defendant’s motion to dismiss the plaintiffs’ negligence per se claims under all four statutes.

The negligence claim also survived the motion to dismiss. The court found that the plaintiffs sufficiently alleged MHI’s failure to encrypt data and demonstrated potential harm resulting from the delayed breach notification.

However, several other claims were dismissed with prejudice. The court rejected the negligence per se claim, ruling that the cited statutes, including the FTC Act and HIPAA, did not establish specific standards of care. Claims of unjust enrichment, bailment, breach of fiduciary duty, and invasion of privacy were also dismissed, with the court finding insufficient grounds for each.

The plaintiffs’ request for declaratory and injunctive relief was denied, as the court determined they lacked standing due to the absence of an imminent threat of another data breach.

Conclusion

This ruling calls attention to the complex legal landscape surrounding data breach cases and highlights the challenges companies face in establishing liability for cybersecurity incidents.

Read the memorandum (PDF) here.

ACA Cybersecurity Resources

At ACA, we understand the importance of cybersecurity for our members. That’s why we’ve created the Cybersecurity Collective, a powerful group designed to address your security concerns head-on.

“In talking to so many ACA members and owners, they consistently tell me cybersecurity threats are the #1 thing that keeps them up at night,” said ACA CEO Scott Purcell. “ACA’s creation of the Cybersecurity Collective is one more step in creating value for our members, so those shouldering the responsibility of protecting your data can have a place to talk about new threats, and new mitigation strategies, to keep those threats at bay.”

When you join the Cybersecurity Collective, you’ll be connected to fellow cybersecurity enthusiasts who are ready to share insights and offer guidance. You’ll also be able to learn and share in our private LinkedIn group.

Don’t miss out on this valuable resource! You or someone on your team can sign up for the Cybersecurity Collective in two easy steps:

Additional security resources:

  • Keep up with cybersecurity news right here
  • Don’t have a strong in-house security team? TPx, our Alliance ACA partner for cybersecurity solutions, is a third-party firm that can help protect your sensitive data against cyber threats. Learn more.
  • Cyber liability insurance coverage is easy and affordable for ACA members. Collectors Insurance Agency (CIA), a subsidiary of ACA, provides members with exclusive access to risk management products and services tailored to each members’ specific needs.
  • All members can listen to our ACA Huddle on cybersecurity insights and our ACA Huddle on client security requests.
  • Members can review this ACA SearchPoint document that addresses security expectations for remote employees.
  • Subscribe to ACA International’s State Guide Cohort and join our monthly webinar series to keep up with state privacy and security requirements.
  • Learn about the newest element of the Federal Trade Commission’s Safeguards Rule, which went into effect earlier this year, right here. Get more information about your Safeguards Rule compliance expectations here.
  • Don’t forget to join our free Cybersecurity Collective!

Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA profile when logged in to acainternational.org.

If you have executive leadership updates or other member news to share with ACA, contact our communications department at comm@acainternational.org. View our publications page for more information and our news submission guidelines here.

One moment please...

Share Profile

This site utilizes cookies as included in our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.