0
Skip to content

Bridging the Credit Gap: The Case for a Pro-Innovation Fintech Framework

Buy now, pay later image with person scrolling on phoneNew research from Professor Todd Zywicki explores how fintech products like BNPL are expanding access to credit for underserved households — and warns that current regulatory hurdles must be cleared to ensure these modern tools can continue to lower costs and drive financial inclusion.

03/02/2026 2:00 P.M.

Technological innovation in consumer finance is a primary driver of competition and financial inclusion in the U.S., and modern products such as Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL), need fair and balanced regulations to offer benefits to consumers and foster innovation.

To ensure that emerging tools like BNPL continue to expand consumer choice and drive market evolution, a balanced regulatory framework is essential — one that protects users without stifling the very innovation that empowers them, according to a research paper from Todd Zywicki, professor of law at George Mason University’s Antonin Scalia Law School. Zywicki also previously served as chair of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau Taskforce of Consumer Financial Law.

“Fintech’s benefits accrue most strongly to consumers historically underserved by the traditional financial system, including younger, lower-income, rural, and minority households,” Zywicki writes in the paper, Facilitating Fintech’s Future: How Congress and Regulation can Support Innovation in Fintech, Earned Wage Access and Buy Now, Pay Later Products. “Drawing on a broad range of empirical research, it shows that fintech products increase access to credit, reduce reliance on high-cost alternatives, lower transaction costs, and mitigate demographic disparities in pricing and approval rates.”

The Threat of Overly Burdensome Regulation

BNPL serves as a modernized version of installment credit, allowing consumers to manage liquidity by spreading out the cost of purchases, often with no interest, according to Zywicki.

Despite these benefits, his report identifies several regulatory risks that could stifle innovation and harm consumer welfare:

  • Inconsistent State Regulations: Disparate state-level rules create complexity and raise costs for providers, which can ultimately limit consumer choice.
  • Arbitrary Asset Thresholds: Regulations tied to specific asset triggers (such as the $10 billion threshold in the Durbin Amendment of the Dodd-Frank Act) can discourage organic growth and lead to “regulatory arbitrage.” Congress should consider revising or removing these limits, which “dampen competition and limit consumer choice.”
  • Incumbent Protection: Overly restrictive regulations may be used by entrenched traditional financial institutions to block new, more competitive entrants.

Policy Recommendations for a Pro-Innovation Framework

To preserve the promise of fintech, Zywicki suggests several regulatory shifts:

  • National Regulatory Coherence: Implementing a coherent national framework that emphasizes proportional oversight and evidence-based intervention.
  • Federal Preemption: Using federal authority to preempt burdensome and inconsistent state laws to allow fintech products to reach their full potential nationwide.
  • Regulatory Sandboxes: Encouraging the use of “sandboxes” to incubate new products and allow for real-time cooperative oversight rather than traditional, after-the-fact enforcement.
  • Modernizing “Threshold” Rules: Revising or eliminating arbitrary asset-based thresholds to ensure functional equivalents in the market are treated consistently.

Future of Fintech

Fintech represents the most consequential wave of financial evolution in decades, offering a path toward more equitable pricing and expanded credit access. But as Zywicki warns, this future depends on “thoughtful” regulation.

“During the past year, there have been several important regulatory developments that have facilitated the continued development of fintech products,” Zywicki notes in the report. “But there are many others that this body and regulators could take that would further support beneficial developments.”

By modernizing threshold rules and supporting a pro-innovation framework, the U.S. can protect the welfare of the underserved while encouraging the very competition that drives costs down, he concludes. The goal is simple: a financial landscape where the rules of the road facilitate growth rather than blocking the path to inclusion.

Interested in more on fintech products and regulations? Check out these articles from ACA International:

Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.

If you have executive leadership updates or other member news to share with ACA, contact our communications department at comm@acainternational.org. View our publications page for more information and our news submission guidelines here.

One moment please...

Share Profile

This site utilizes cookies as included in our Privacy Policy and User Agreement.