The case, which stems from the firing of FTC Commissioner Rebecca Slaughter, questions whether a president has the constitutional authority to remove agency leaders without cause. The court’s decision, expected in summer 2026, could reshape the independence of numerous federal bodies, including the FTC.
12/19/2025 1:30 P.M.
3 minute read
The U.S Supreme Court held oral arguments in a case focused on the executive branch’s authority to remove leaders of federal agencies — specifically, the Federal Trade Commission.
One of the FTC’s commissioners, Rebecca Slaughter, was fired in March 2025 and was reinstated after challenging the decision in district court.
Her district court lawsuit claimed the firing violated the Federal Trade Commission Act and a 1935 Supreme Court decision protecting officials at independent agencies, ACA International previously reported on Slaughter’s case.
The case went to the Supreme Court, with precedent from the 1935 decision in Humphrey’s Executor v. United States at its center.
Slaughter and the Trump administration address two questions in the Supreme Court case:
- “Whether the removal protections for FTC commissioners conflict with the Constitution’s allocation of powers among the branches of government, ‘and, if so, whether Humphrey’s Executor … should be overruled,’” and
- “Whether, even if government officials like Slaughter are improperly removed from office, federal courts have the power to order their reinstatement or retention.”
Oral Arguments
Following the Dec. 8, 2025, oral arguments, a summary from SCOTUSblog.com reporter Amy Howe said a majority of the justices appeared to be in favor of overturning the federal law that prevents a president from firing agency heads, in this case the Federal Trade Commission.
“A solid majority of the justices appeared to agree with the Trump administration that a law prohibiting the president from firing FTC commissioners except in cases of ‘inefficiency, neglect of duty, or malfeasance in office’ violates the constitutional separation of powers between the three branches of government,” Howe writes.
Leading up to the oral arguments, three justices disagreed with considering Slaughter’s case: Elena Kagan, Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson.
In Kagan’s dissent (PDF), she specified that in Humphrey’s Executor, “the President cannot, as he concededly did here, fire an FTC commissioner without any reason.”
To reach a different outcome, Kagan notes, “requires reversing the rule stated in Humphrey’s.”
If that occurred, and the court decided in favor of the Trump administration, Howe writes it “would significantly increase the president’s power over not only the FTC but roughly two dozen other multi-member agencies that Congress intended to be independent.”
She adds that the arguments also focused on possible widespread effects of a ruling in the case for Trump or Slaughter. If they decide in Slaughter’s favor, Congress could have significant power to switch departments to multi-member agencies protected from the president’s actions, according to Howe.
However, a ruling for the Trump administration could impact not only federal agencies but also entities such as the U.S. Tax Court, which have similar removal requirements.
Howe concludes, “Although there seemed to be a clear majority that was ready to rule that Trump has the power to fire FTC commissioners, it was less certain whether the justices were ready to take the additional step of overruling Humphrey’s Executor.”
Read additional insights on the SCOTUSblog post for Trump v. Slaughter.
A decision in the case could be made in June or July 2026.
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.
The case, which stems from the firing of FTC Commissioner Rebecca Slaughter, questions whether a president has the constitutional authority to remove agency leaders without cause. The court’s decision, expected in summer 2026, could reshape the independence of numerous federal bodies, including the FTC.





