Research revealed that major cybersecurity incidents can lead to an average 9% decrease in shareholder value within a year.
06/30/2025 11:00 A.M.
3 minute read
Reputational damage ranks among the top 10 risks facing organizations, according to Aon’s Global Risk Management Survey. This has been a consistent concern since 2007, Aon found, reflecting the growing importance of managing reputation in a volatile environment.
The Impact of Cyber Events on Company Value
Research shows that mishandling cyber events can lead to severe consequences, including erosion of consumer and employee trust, which in turn affects sales and brand value.
Quantifying reputation risk has historically been challenging, but Aon’s analysis of 47 prominent cyber events in 2023 revealed that major incidents can lead to an average 9% decrease in shareholder value within a year. This highlights the importance of proactively understanding and managing cyber risks.
Aon’s research classified 1,414 cyber events reported through the end of 2024 into five categories:
- Malware/Ransomware: These attacks disrupt access to systems and demand ransom payments. They account for 60% of reputation risk events but only 45% of all cyber events.
- Unauthorized Access and Credentials Attacks: These involve gaining unauthorized access to networks or systems.
- Human Factors: These stem from employee errors, such as falling for phishing scams.
- System Exploits: Attackers exploit system vulnerabilities, often injecting malicious code.
- Network and System Attacks: These compromise system integrity, such as denial of service attacks.
While malware/ransomware attacks are most likely to become reputation risk events, network and system attacks tend to have the most severe impact, causing a 51% fall in shareholder value. The correlation between the likelihood of an event becoming a reputation risk and its severity is weak, as media attention often drives the former, while the direct impact on consumers influences the latter.
The Five Drivers of Value Recovery
To mitigate reputation risks, Aon found that businesses should focus on five key drivers of value recovery:
- Preparedness: Develop analytical insights to understand reputation risks and prevent potential losses.
- Leadership: Demonstrate strong and visible leadership during events.
- Action: Respond rapidly and credibly to incidents.
- Communication: Communicate openly and honestly about the event and response.
- Change: Show remorse and commit to meaningful change post-event.
These drivers can help mitigate shareholder value destruction and potentially enhance reputation. Aon’s 2023 research found that companies navigating cyber attacks effectively saw an average increase in shareholder value of 18%, while those that struggled experienced a 21% drop.
How ACA Can Help
Cyber incidents can directly impact company value—especially when it comes time to sell your agency. ACA International is dedicated to helping members in safeguarding their operations, client data, and consumer information.
Collectors Insurance Agency Inc. (CIA), a subsidiary of ACA, has partnered with Coalition, a leading cyber insurance provider that can proactively reduce cyber risks for ACA member companies. Coalition offers a comprehensive cyber risk management platform that helps clients detect, assess, and mitigate cyber threats throughout the life of a cyber insurance policy.
Coalition has demonstrated success in reducing claims frequency by 73% compared to the industry average. This active risk management approach involves partnering with policyholders to minimize risks throughout the policy lifecycle, rather than waiting for claims to occur.
For ACA members, the partnership between CIA and Coalition offers unique advantages:
- Pre-bind access to Coalition Control for risk assessment.
- Data-driven approach to cyber risk mitigation.
- Comprehensive coverage at competitive rates.
- Proactive security monitoring and support.
- World-class claims handling when needed.
ACA members interested in learning more about Coalition’s cyber insurance offerings through Collectors Insurance Agency can contact CIA at collectorsinsurance@acainternational.org or 952-928-8000 (ext. 4).
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA Assistant profile when logged in to acainternational.org.
Research revealed that major cybersecurity incidents can lead to an average 9% decrease in shareholder value within a year.





