The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals vacated the FCC’s one-to-one consent rule on the grounds the FCC exceeded its statutory authority under the TCPA.
02/05/2025 12:45 P.M.
4 minute read
Key Takeaways:
- The FCC’s one-to-one consent rule will not take effect after a decision in the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals.
- These rules only apply to telemarketing calls but signal how some courts approach TCPA issues.
- The FCC’s new rules regarding how consumers may revoke previously granted consent to receive autodialed calls or texts or prerecorded or artificial voice calls is still expected to take effect on April 11, 2025.
—
The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals has tossed out a Federal Communications Commission rule purporting to close the “lead generator loophole” by requiring telemarketers to obtain individualized consent from consumers before making a robocall.
The FCC was attempting to address a concern that lead generators would use websites to obtain consent from a consumer to be contacted by numerous individual sellers. To accomplish this goal, the FCC interpreted the Telephone Consumer Protection Act’s prior express consent provision to require that a consumer must consent to receive calls from only one entity at a time, and that the consent only apply to calls whose subject matter is “logically and topically associated with the interaction that prompted the consent.”
For example, a comparison-shopping website for insurance products could not be used to obtain consent about vacation rentals. Again, these rules only apply to telemarketing calls. The rules were slated to take effect on Jan. 27, 2025.
In its Jan. 24 decision, the 11th Circuit held that the FCC’s one-to-one consent rule conflicted with the ordinary statutory meaning of prior express consent. As a result, the court vacated the FCC’s interpretation, and this rule is dead for now.
Although not cited frequently, the court decision may have been influenced by the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo removing deference to agency interpretations. It seems clear the court placed no bearing on the FCC’s interpretation and undertook its own, fully independent review of the statutory language.
Shortly before the court’s ruling, the FCC issued its own order delaying the effective date of the rule pending the completion of 11th Circuit’s review. The order delayed the effective date for one year. Given that the court vacated the rule, it will not go into effect unless or until the FCC addresses the issue again.
What’s Next?
“It is unclear whether the FCC will take up this issue again in light of new FCC Chairman Brendan Carr’s interest in reducing regulation,” said Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck Shareholder Michael Pryor. “The court ruling does not affect the requirement that telemarketers obtain prior express written consent before making robocalls to consumers.”
Nor does the ruling affect the other provisions in the FCC’s December 2023 order (PDF) relating to texting. Those other aspects of the 2023 order require terminating mobile wireless providers to block text messages from a particular number following notification from the FCC unless their investigation determines that the identified text messages are not illegal; codified that the National Do Not Call Registry’s protections apply to text messages; and encouraged providers to make email-to-text a service that consumers proactively opt into.
ACA International will continue to provide updates to members on the status of the rules and related proceedings at the FCC.
Revocation of Consent Order and President Trump’s Executive Order
Meanwhile, the FCC’s order codifying new rules regarding how consumers may revoke previously granted consent to receive autodialed calls or texts or prerecorded or artificial voice calls is still expected to take effect on April 11, 2025, ACA previously reported.
ACA was deeply involved in the development of these rules to update the FCC’s initial proposal that would have required callers to honor revocation requests within 24 hours, ACA previously reported. ACA advocated for a 10-business-day period, which the FCC adopted in its final rules. ACA also sought and obtained several critical revisions once a draft of the final order (PDF) was released.
One of President Donald Trump’s recent executive orders asked executive agencies to pause for 60 days from the date of the executive order rules that have not yet gone into effect. It is unclear whether the executive order applies to independent agencies like the FCC or would apply to rules whose effective date lies outside the 60-day pause.
“Nevertheless, the executive order reflects an administrative decision to take a second look at rules and appears consistent with Chairman Carr’s regulatory philosophy,” Pryor said. “There may thus be an opportunity to revisit the revocation rule before it goes into effect in April.”
Remember, subscribe to ACA Daily and Member Alerts under your My ACA profile when logged in to acainternational.org to receive updates on the ACA Huddle.
The 11th Circuit Court of Appeals vacated the FCC’s one-to-one consent rule on the grounds the FCC exceeded its statutory authority under the TCPA.





